Barry Presents: Sergio Leone Mafia / Una Mafia Del West Game Thread

[Comrade Khan]

Would Smark have argued the semantics of a governor role that hard and then conceded that it was probably scum for the usage this game if he was scum? The original "it's likely town" argument looks bad for him but once we got down to how it was used this game he seemed to drop that.

Smark will argue anything to death as either alignment, so it's non indicative for me.

 

[Smart Marx]

Would Smark have argued the semantics of a governor role that hard and then conceded that it was probably scum for the usage this game if he was scum? The original "it's likely town" argument looks bad for him but once we got down to how it was used this game he seemed to drop that.

I was arguing the original governor role that overturns a lynch while can be scum is designed to be town.

This role that just stops day doesn't seem to have any town usage so probably is scum.

 

[Odo]

Scum motivation for it is if you wait til he has 6-7 votes then it’s obvious it’s scum

with only 4 you have room to manoeuvre

however I’m not willing to abandon the entirety of the days play based on a usage I think was shit, sorry

 

[Smart Marx]

Smark will argue anything to death as either alignment, so it's non indicative for me.

I'm far less likely to argue if I'm scum.

Though, when I'm trying to teach Chris how to play mafia and I know how roles work. I can see myself doing that as scum, too.

 

[Odo]

I’m irritated that you’ve all gone to the well of trying to rationalise scum role action choices and abandoned the play

 

[PHEN0M]

Did you read why I did it?

i got there eventually, still funny.

 

[Chris]

I'm far less likely to argue if I'm scum.

Though, when I'm trying to teach Chris how to play mafia and I know how roles work. I can see myself doing that as scum, too.

I ain't need no teacher don't let that coaching narrative come back again

 

[Lethal]

I'm far less likely to argue if I'm scum.

Though, when I'm trying to teach Chris how to play mafia and I know how roles work. I can see myself doing that as scum, too.

Coaching in a QT

 

[Smart Marx]

Scum motivation for it is if you wait til he has 6-7 votes then it’s obvious it’s scum

with only 4 you have room to manoeuvre

however I’m not willing to abandon the entirety of the days play based on a usage I think was shit, sorry

Not really. If the Governor was town, if it had been a governor, all they have to do is believe I'm town.

Stopping a day early when they had plenty of time to move the lynch elsewhere seems strange af to me.

 

[Smart Marx]

I ain't need no teacher don't let that coaching narrative come back again

Either way, Odo was saying I was lying to you and I wasn't.

 

[Comrade Khan]

I’m irritated that you’ve all gone to the well of trying to rationalise scum role action choices and abandoned the play

I mean, I haven't and still think the logical answer is that he's scum, as that's the simplest solution, and is in most cases the right solution.
Hoping non-scum shootas help us tonight

 

[Chris]

I’m irritated that you’ve all gone to the well of trying to rationalise scum role action choices and abandoned the play

I'm still sticking with my thoughts before the usage. I don't like Smark's play but I didn't want to lynch him on D1, and I still wanna go after OMB.

 

[Smart Marx]

Coaching in a QT

Would be a nice theory if I wasn't clearly doing it in thread.

 

[PHEN0M]

Whatever ended Day was a scum role.

 

[Odo]

Not really. If the Governor was town, if it had been a governor, all they have to do is believe I'm town.

Stopping a day early when they had plenty of time to move the lynch elsewhere seems strange af to me.

please stop with this line of thought. What the role is called doesn’t matter, what it does, does.

there’s no way whoever used the role is town. None. 0.