Barry Presents: Sergio Leone Mafia / Una Mafia Del West Game Thread

[Chris]

Whatever ended Day was a scum role.

I'm new here can you please give me hotter takes than ones I've already decided myself to help the newbie out

 

[Odo]

I'm still sticking with my thoughts before the usage. I don't like Smark's play but I didn't want to lynch him on D1, and I still wanna go after OMB.

I’ve no issue with you, your positions are consistent

 

[Odo]

I mean, I haven't and still think the logical answer is that he's scum, as that's the simplest solution, and is in most cases the right solution.
Hoping non-scum shootas help us tonight

remind me to come back to this post if there’s a bus driver claim at any stage

 

[Smart Marx]

please stop with this line of thought. What the role is called doesn’t matter, what it does, does.

there’s no way whoever used the role is town. None. 0.

What it does isn't a Governor role. Governor's don't stop day uless there was a lynch.

That's very important when discussing if it could be townie or not.

And I agree now that we know it wasn't a governor.

 

[Comrade Khan]

shooting one or both of OMB and Smark would be met joy, me thinks?

 

[Comrade Khan]

remind me to come back to this post if there’s a bus driver claim at any stage

sure. But that does remind me, did you get what you wanted out of Brutus? What's your read on him? I just realized I forgot to re-ask you this as you claimed to be 6 beers in last night.

 

[Odo]

What it does isn't a Governor role. Governor's don't stop day uless there was a lynch.

That's very important when discussing if it could be townie or not.

And I agree now that we know it wasn't a governor.

have you noticed how nobody else cares what the role is called? Because it’s totally irrelevant?

we’ve had roles with this functionality called a governor, a mayor and I’m sure something else too - it has 0 relevance. It’s a scum role

 

[Odo]

sure. But that does remind me, did you get what you wanted out of Brutus? What's your read on him? I just realized I forgot to re-ask you this as you claimed to be 6 beers in last night.

not really, he’s on my scum shortlist as a result

 

[Smart Marx]

have you noticed how nobody else cares what the role is called? Because it’s totally irrelevant?

we’ve had roles with this functionality called a governor, a mayor and I’m sure something else too - it has 0 relevance. It’s a scum role

If it stops day without a lynch, it's very relevant.

Sorry that hurts your ego. The point is, they could have used it when it appeared I was lynched and it hid it better.

Using this role on 3 votes is just mind boggling.

 

[Odo]

Can someone else explain to smark why it’s a scum role please

 

[Chris]

Can someone else explain to smark why it’s a scum role please

Seems like he's been agreeing with that since he decided it wasn't called "governor"

 

[Odo]

While you’re there, ask him why he thinks there was a question of him being lynched, when he only had 4 vites

unless he thinks the phantom executioner and phantom town governor communicated psychically

or that the phantom town governor has elected to stay silent just for the lols

 

[Comrade Khan]

not really, he’s on my scum shortlist as a result

ty for letting us know

 

[Smart Marx]

It is a scum role because it isn't a governor. Not sure why you don't grasp that.

 

[Banez]

OMB

Cheers, i was like "I dont remember this player"

I still dont but atleast i know whats their actual nickname.