Barry Presents: Sergio Leone Mafia / Una Mafia Del West Game Thread

[RDK]

Yes, it’s a fucking Blue role to give, and the moment you use it, you’re an idiot if you’re town

well i could see it being useful for stopping quick hammers perhaps which would make it a decent town counter for DV if Smark is scum

 

[Odo]

So how do you think you were lynched then?
You were initially convinced it was a town usage

 

[Tweet]

I don't really like Odo arguing like Smark is still thinking the role is a town role in this game when he's been saying it's scum for pages and is really only hung up on whether "governor" is the name of the role

Can we just call it sheriff for me please

I'll call it something else entirely

 

[Chris]

im not arguing that at all. I’m arguing he tried to misrepresent it at first but realised it was dumb to even try, cause I don’t believe he’s actually stupid enough to have even entertained it being a town usage

I think this is true if Smark's scum easily

I din't misrepresent anything. I legit believed I was lynched. I've never seen a role that strops day without a lynch.

I think this is also true and if he was scum idk why he'd come in thinking he was saved from a 3 vote lynch or however many votes were actually on him at the time. Smark not paying attention to how many votes are on him doesn't feel like a scum or town tell, just odd for him personally though.

 

[Odo]

well i could see it being useful for stopping quick hammers perhaps which would make it a decent town counter for DV if Smark is scum

yesbut in the one niche situation you can use it, you’re in lylo anyway, meaning even if you stop the lynch, the subsequent night end probably ends the game

and in 2 years here, I’ve only seen a handful of quick lynches like what you’re describing

 

[Smart Marx]

So how do you think you were lynched then?
You were initially convinced it was a town usage

Because I never got to read back with all this fun we're doign rn.

When day ended with the no lynch and people started talking about a governor, I naturally assumed I was lynched.

 

[Odo]

Then let’s examine how and why you thought you were lynched, it seems relevant

 

[Chris]

The reply to Smark's quote should say "I think this is also true if he's town" as I'm on the fence still

 

[Smart Marx]

Then let’s examine how and why you thought you were lynched, it seems relevant

I already explained.

 

[Odo]

You thought you were lynched because the word governor was used

that’s laughable

do you have no opinion on the mechanics of such a lynch?

 

[Leon TrotSky]

please stop with this line of thought. What the role is called doesn’t matter, what it does, does.

there’s no way whoever used the role is town. None. 0.

Maybe Smark has reason to defend whoever used the role

 

[Comrade Khan]

I'll call it something else entirely

View attachment 3602

sick game tbh

 

[Smart Marx]

Yes. Mention a role, know how that roles works. Assume that's what happened.

 

[Odo]

At this stage, I think you are just trolling because you don’t have anything better, and I would urge my fellow players to disregard anything you say from here

 

[Tweet]

sick game tbh

I never finished it, barely remember it tbh. Except for a few things like the SHERF.