Barry Presents: an Oversimplified MAFIA Game Thread

[Marty McFourth]

Yea, I don't really think what Haza did tells me his alignment. But..it makes more sense for him to do that as town than scum because why give me an easy out when I've got a decent amount of pressure on my tail

 

[RDK]

Considering that particular thought process of mine, scum Haza would make most sense with non-scum TFW (because if you were co-scum why wouldn't you just feed him that line in scum chat?? and also for reasons above.

But either way it looks bad, and I want to resolve TFW first of all

well there you go, you've just named the second reason why your post on me is absolute nonsense all by yourself

 

[RDK]

I don't really believe there is any way Sky makes that post as town actually. Like she legit saw Jeff's post i'm pretty sure and was like this might be a good time to sus X for Y after that post. The theory is absolute trash because if me and TFW were both scum i'd just tell him how to defend himself. And if I'm scum and TFW is town why would I want to give anyone a reason not to suspect the guy under the most suspicion that hasn't even claimed yet?

The fact Sky now wants to continue to pursue TFW having established me as the next phase target and connected me with TFW regardless of his flip based on nonsense reasons leaves me with little doubt she is not pro-town here.

Vote: Sky

 

[Chris]

I agree Haza did give TFW a defense to use (would have preferred TFW explain more first) but I dont think there was anything scummy about it. He simply made an observation on a post and generated a read out of it lol

 

[Chris]

I don't really believe there is any way Sky makes that post as town actually. Like she legit saw Jeff's post i'm pretty sure and was like this might be a good time to sus X for Y after that post. The theory is absolute trash because if me and TFW were both scum i'd just tell him how to defend himself. And if I'm scum and TFW is town why would I want to give anyone a reason not to suspect the guy under the most suspicion that hasn't even claimed yet?

The fact Sky now wants to continue to pursue TFW having established me as the next phase target and connected me with TFW regardless of his flip based on nonsense reasons leaves me with little doubt she is not pro-town here.

Vote: Sky

White knighting a townie is the only reason I can think of as far as being scum and TFW being town but agreed, if doesn't seem like particularly optimal play if that's the case. Scum would more than likely see if he's forced to claim first before really defending

 

[Poyser]

I don't really believe there is any way Sky makes that post as town actually. Like she legit saw Jeff's post i'm pretty sure and was like this might be a good time to sus X for Y after that post. The theory is absolute trash because if me and TFW were both scum i'd just tell him how to defend himself. And if I'm scum and TFW is town why would I want to give anyone a reason not to suspect the guy under the most suspicion that hasn't even claimed yet?

The fact Sky now wants to continue to pursue TFW having established me as the next phase target and connected me with TFW regardless of his flip based on nonsense reasons leaves me with little doubt she is not pro-town here.

Vote: Sky

vote haza

 

[RDK]

I agree Haza did give TFW a defense to use (would have preferred TFW explain more first) but I dont think there was anything scummy about it. He simply made an observation on a post and generated a read out of it lol

But you can't use a defense that someone else gave you and claim it as your own defense. As we just saw by Jeff's post lol. So suggesting my intention were mal is just an excessive reach.

 

[RDK]

White knighting a townie is the only reason I can think of as far as being scum and TFW being town but agreed, if doesn't seem like particularly optimal play if that's the case. Scum would more than likely see if he's forced to claim first before really defending

They hadn't even claimed lol, would be far too early for a white knighting play

 

[Marty McFourth]

Okay, I entirely thought King K. Rool was Lethal Banks.

Who is King K. Rool then?

smark

Thanks.

Vote: King K. Rool.

What led to you voting Smark here, Retep?

 

[PHEN0M]

Vote: Haza

 

[Poyser]

There’s a few reasons for my vote on haza

but I’ll give town points to the first one to correctly point out the massive red flag in his posts

 

[Leon TrotSky]

There’s a few reasons for my vote on haza

but I’ll give town points to the first one to correctly point out the massive red flag in his posts

The defence being based on self meta read is a pretty big one for me, though I'm not sure if you're as against self meta as I am

 

[RDK]

Poyser probably town, usually when he does red flag shtick it's because he actually believes in it (and himself), think he's less likely to search for red flags when he's scum bc he isn't actively scum hunting (although if he sees something he can use then it's possible he would point it out so it's not a cert town read but v likely id say)

 

[Tweet]

vote Chris

 

[Tweet]

Not particularly fond of TFW at this stage either