Barry Presents: an Oversimplified MAFIA Game Thread

[Chris]

vote Chris

Damn what i do?

 

[RDK]

Poyser can you let Phenom explain his vote on me before you do pls

 

[Poyser]

Poyser probably town, usually when he does red flag shtick it's because he actually believes in it (and himself), think he's less likely to search for red flags when he's scum bc he isn't actively scum hunting (although if he sees something he can use then it's possible he would point it out so it's not a cert town read but v likely id say)

I don’t really believe you’d give me a town read so easily tbh

 

[Kross Rhodes]

Giving Poyser a town read only halfway through day 1 feels extremely foolhardy unless you got a good reason.

 

[RDK]

I don’t really believe you’d give me a town read so easily tbh

Not a bad point at all admittedly. I am usually very cautious to even lean on you, odo or magic as you have such a wide scum range. This is why I added the caution to the end of the read, but your enthusiasm for whatever red flag you feel you have seen seemed genuine to me.

 

[Marty McFourth]

Giving Poyser a town read only halfway through day 1 feels extremely foolhardy unless you got a good reason.

I was about to say Poyser was feeling town to me The nature in which he suspected me (which feels reminscent of his past town games) and Haza vote are the reasons.

 

[Marty McFourth]

I personally haven't played with Haza enough to where I'd feel comfortable tipping my hat either way, but right now he's null. I still think the way he put himself out there regarding me felt more town than anything else. I can see the merits of what other people are saying, just not sure how to read him myself.

 

[Marty McFourth]

Tweet voting Chris is...interesting to say the least, because I was thinking to myself how town he feels from the start. I would actually go as far to say he's my strongest town read at the moment, well as strong as a Day 1 town read can be. His posts feel natural.

 

[Marty McFourth]

Is Tweet more likely to go against the grain as town or scum?

 

[Chris]

Is Tweet more likely to go against the grain as town or scum?

Probably as town I'd say? Not sure he kinda does his own thing as either alignment I think tbh

I wouldn't really consider voting me going against the grain either tho tbf. I think you're the only one that's mentioned me as town

 

[RDK]

Post 277 by Poyser in clocktower 2 when he was town jumped immediately to mind when he voted me here btw. That time he was right about me being scum this time he is wrong being the difference. But yeah I think it's a confidence and a genuine scum hunting tell of his which is why I'm leaning. I've not seen him give assertive red flag suggestions as scum but as I said I wouldn't rule it out of his scum range.

It's possible he does it too and I just haven't noticed it like I noticed the one I just referenced because I wasn't the subject in the others. I'd be happy for someone to point me to references if it is the case that he throws up highly confident flag reads as scum

 

[Marty McFourth]

Probably as town I'd say? Not sure he kinda does his own thing as either alignment I think tbh

I wouldn't really consider voting me going against the grain either tho tbf. I think you're the only one that's mentioned me as town

I have? Well, alright

I meant it in more as his own wagon, but yeah I feel like I've seen him do that more as town as I try to think back. Although he's not really the type to play follow the leader I would say.

 

[Marty McFourth]

Post 277 by Poyser in clocktower 2 when he was town jumped immediately to mind when he voted me here btw. That time he was right about me being scum this time he is wrong being the difference. But yeah I think it's a confidence and a genuine scum hunting tell of his which is why I'm leaning. I've not seen him give assertive red flag suggestions as scum but as I said I wouldn't rule it out of his scum range.

It's possible he does it too and I just haven't noticed it like I noticed the one I just referenced because I wasn't the subject in the others. I'd be happy for someone to point me to references if it is the case that he throws up highly confident flag reads as scum

I do remember last time I played with Poyser he quoted a post by a user named Maestro and instantly flagged it down it as a red flag (off my memory here), and I do think that guy flipped scum in that game. His play is striking me of what I would normally expect when he's town but he's competent either way.

 

[Marty McFourth]

I don't really trust Smark as much after a POE of him. I know scum hunting isn't exactly his forte in Day 1, but he's really leaning in to asking questions this game a lot. Not that it's a bad thing, but if you want to look productive as scum than asking questions is exactly how to do it. He's really good at vibing natural.

 

[Kross Rhodes]

I don't really trust Smark as much after a POE of him. I know scum hunting isn't exactly his forte in Day 1, but he's really leaning in to asking questions this game a lot. Not that it's a bad thing, but if you want to look productive as scum than asking questions is exactly how to do it. He's really good at vibing natural.

Asking questions is mainly what I do as either alignment. Especially on day 1.

I'm also trying to chill this game so I don't get too worked up.