You'd take rivers over eli? I mean, I guess in a really pussy west coast offense where your number one threat is LT, Woodhead, or Sproles. As long as you keep the routes 5 yards he can get it there with that noodle.
Thank you for actually hitting a good point. Eli didn't have time at all this year to do a damn thing with the ball. Hakeem nicks quit playing, and despite the 0-6 start (with 5 different running backs) we managed to put up a respectable season. What the giants did last year was prove they have heart, and that's all a fan asks for. We will be fine. Eli is a good starting quarterback, and I reckon he has another super run in him before he calls it quits. I don't think we have the talent now to make another amazing run, but I said the same thing before. We had the best off-season in the NFC East. We got starters in every spot we needed besides one (besides TE) We are ight. I know everyone keys on Desean to Washington but overall the Giants made the MOST improvements to their team. Eli has a hell of an arm, but he does make unwise decisions when faced with pressure. I don't know why, but he has always done it. He tries to hit the home run ball too much and throws some picks here or there. In crunch time he rarely and I mean rarely doesn't come through. That is something rivers struggles with. Over the years i've seen the chargers lose quite a bit of close games(17 fourth quarter comebacks, 20 game-winning drives) meanwhile the giants win them.(25 fourth quarter comebacks, 30 game-winning drives for Eli. TWO 4TH QUARTER COMEBACKS AND GAME WINNING DRIVES IN THE SUPERBOWL) The same thing that he is hated for, is also a dream to have in the 4th quarter. He doesn't let any mistake reflect how he plays in crunch time. It's like it never happened, but WHY can't you just play in 3 quarters like you do in the 4th ELI!? That's the downside to Eli... In the 4th, outside of Brady, Brees, Manning(big) I'd take no other QB.
Don't get me wrong, I don't think Eli is a top 5 QB. Maybe top 10, but I'd take Eli over Rivers. That's just me.