Paul as in CP3? You don't think the best PG in the NBA is a max player?
No.
The best PG in the league performs like the best fucking pg in the league in the playoffs. He does not get evenly matched or outplayed his whole playoff life by his individual matchups. Billups dusted him something awful in Denver, Conley basically washed him last year, and Parker has played him even if not better their playoff matchups. The best pg in the league doesn't let his team lose with hca in a series multiple times. The best pg in the league in the regular season doesn't get routinely obliterated by Rondo or. Deron. The best in the world at their position does what Kobe does to sgs like Manu, Bron to SFs, MJ did to Clyde, and the like in a postseason which he's never once displayed.
can you name aeries where Paul took over? Even in a loss he's never had that. Vince moment or Tracy moment where you say he played his ass off and was the best guy for a series but team didnt show like a top player
CP3 is an all star pg, not a superstar. He can't be your best player if you want playoff success. Stockton was a superstar pg and his offenses remained elite on the playoffs where Paul's fall off when keyed in on. Payton locked fuckers up at pg or SG to elevate his team in the playoffs. Kidd led his team to b2b finals while locking guys up, scoring, running a top O, and rebounding like a man and logging big minutes. We don't even have to touch on what Magic or Isiah did in playoff basketball.
Paul provides too many limitations to be deemed a superstar or max guy. He doesn't outplay his position in a series. He isn't a great defender, he's excellent help but not man. He can't get you big points over a series. He can't log 40 minutes a night in a series. He's never played a full season. He lacks a piece of a meniscus. He needs a minute cap during the season in what should be his prime. He's a regular season pg and all star in a league filled with all star PGs.
The last superstar pg was. Kidd in NJ in terms of impact and winning .. Not Deron, not Paul, not Nash, not Rondo ... And a pg doesn't win you a title in this league either over the past two decades, so no hell no I wouldn't max him