World of Horror: An End of the World MAFIA Game Thread

[Maestro]

there's likely 4 members left

why dont you have any town reads

i do have town reads, nom and pendex. but why is that needed right now?

 

[Poyser]

i do have town reads, nom and pendex. but why is that needed right now?

They are your only town reads???

Town reads are always needed and always important lol, you have to narrow the suspect pool down. Something you dont really seem interested in doing at all

 

[Canadian Dragon]

@Poyser regarding Chris, his early play seemed like usual chris but hes pretty good at being logical as both alignments I guess. i also think it would be rather harsh for scum to have a bomb and a pgo. unless hes simply lying about PGO and pulling the ol ODO classic, but again, thats wifom

 

[Poyser]

Ahhhh I forgot about the bomb, yeah Im disregarding chris from poe

 

[Maestro]

Isn't Mafia literally all about speculating and making assumptions about people's motives?

Not really grasping, I was just pointing out what you said didn't make a whole lot of sense to me.

you are not getting the point, speculating is needed but that cannot be the sole reason to a lynch, you dont know how i play for you or whoever to say i am scum because of the play style, you know that doesnt make sense if you are honest.

in what way it didnt make sense?

 

[Poyser]

another bit of setup spec is phen0m being a miller when our main investigation role was a gunsmith, lol

 

[Poyser]

you are not getting the point, speculating is needed but that cannot be the sole reason to a lynch, you dont know how i play for you or whoever to say i am scum because of the play style, you know that doesnt make sense if you are honest.

in what way it didnt make sense?

So then what is needed for a lynch??? 100% proof???

 

[Poyser]

One thing I noticed from doing my combinations is that pendex is in almost all of the combos (apart from the ones that include doddsy, but i still wanna assume hes town)

 

[Marty McFourth]

Chris is like one of my strongest town reads and has vibed that way all game. Plus the way he was hinting at his role and everything else, felt very geniune. Makes no sense for him to be scum. It's why I want to know where his vote would lie tbh, I trust him

 

[Poyser]

but then if maestro is scum, then bussing him probably makes sense i guess so might not be that simple

 

[Canadian Dragon]

another bit of setup spec is phen0m being a miller when our main investigation role was a gunsmith, lol

Phenom is a weird one like I said in my post. He;s playing with way more fervor than last game which is different, but that's burned me before. And I can also somewhat explain the big balls because hes acting like es confirmed. I guess the only question is would he fake that and then play accordingly? I'm not sure. Obviously was fucking annoying getting tunneled and he never gave me a read list I asked for I dont think, that did make me sad.

 

[Maestro]

Then elaborate on your shade, I'm not a mind reader n saying shit without receipts is scummy a.f

but thats what you've been doing though, but if you want the reason, i'll say it again, your roles are pretty much counterclaim to one another, so it doesnt make much sense to not read the other scummy.

 

[Maestro]

So then what is needed for a lynch??? 100% proof???

so you are admitting you are lynching me because you dont know my playstyle? or what because i am not getting the point.

 

[Canadian Dragon]

but thats what you've been doing though, but if you want the reason, i'll say it again, your roles are pretty much counterclaim to one another, so it doesnt make much sense to not read the other scummy.

I don't solely base my reads on over lapping roles, that's a fools errand especially with this host. I also trust my instincts when it comes to town reads, and outside of role spec, fourth has played pretty damn towny in my eyes.

ANd I also think I've done a pretty good job at attaching my reasons for any and all reads ive provided. try again

 

[Marty McFourth]

another bit of setup spec is phen0m being a miller when our main investigation role was a gunsmith, lol

There is cop shots out there though, I recieved one with my role. I want to say Phenom is probably legit, but I'd be impressed if he's scum as he's been very involved.