Push
Rusev: Since he debuted, he's only gotten better. His in ring work has been solid, his charisma and entertainment skills have been stand out, and he's finding his way to get over
Becky Lynch: The most underutilized woman on the roster, hands down. She's technically sound in the ring, brings a good energy, and is a babyface to get behind.
Rhyno: This is my personal fantasy, but Rhyno has always seemed underappreciated by a majority of fans. I still hope to see him get a singles title run before he hangs up the boots.
De-Push
Finn Bálor: I've never been sold on Finn. He's solid in the ring, but besides putting on makeup for his blowoff matches, I just find no ability ti care about him.
Jason Jordan: Even though the storyline with him being Angle's son kinda dying, he's yet to really show anything beyond "I am a good technical wrestler". Splitting up AA has hurt more than it helped.
Charlotte: Since she made it to the main roster, Charlotte has been the Roman Reigns of the Women's Division. She's been overexposed, and it's really hard to care about anything she does.
Fire
Dolph Ziggler: It's done. I don't care about Dolph. Dolph doesn't care about Dolph. WWE doesn't care about Dolph. Let. It. Go.