Trailer Park Boys Mafia - GAME THREAD

[Chris]

Your responses to me that game were a glorified "git gud" so ya, fairly similar

 

[RetepAdam.]

I'd point this out as a towny thing to do but I seem to remember having played a game with a lot of scum goodguying so...

(I was also once accused of goodguying despite being town)

Because a game shouldn't be ruined by having a scum team with no theme knowledge (see: Game Show Mafia)

I'm pretty sure I buddied hard to Jeff that game and he flipped scum

These were pretty much your first posts after putting the double vote out there.

 

[Sky]

These were pretty much your first posts after putting the double vote out there.

There's a big difference between idle reminiscing and pulling out quotes to prove a point, don't you think?

 

[RetepAdam.]

There's a big difference between idle reminiscing and pulling out quotes to prove a point, don't you think?

Right, but that's what you did last game too. That's why I noticed it right out of the gate.

 

[Sky]

Right, but that's what you did last game too. That's why I noticed it right out of the gate.

Really flimsy reason to suspect someone, though. Especially when none of it was really related to a case

 

[Tweet]

I just want to completely think it through. Started to feel like I'm jumping to an early conclusion.

I guess my problem lies within you apparently already having an idea of what lynching and claiming means

 

[RetepAdam.]

Really flimsy reason to suspect someone, though. Especially when none of it was really related to a case

Like I said, theory.

 

[Sky]

Like I said, theory.

Theory, sure, but it feels like straw-grasping. Do not like it one bit.

 

[Hidden Blaze]

I guess my problem lies within you apparently already having an idea of what lynching and claiming means

i could understand knowing what lynching means. I knew that my first game because it’s pretty self-explanatory. The claim thing I could see being maybe something a newbie wouldn’t know. Again going off my own experience from when I played my first

 

[RetepAdam.]

Theory, sure, but it feels like straw-grasping. Do not like it one bit.

See, this is why I just keep to myself on Day 1.

 

[Tweet]

i could understand knowing what lynching means. I knew that my first game because it’s pretty self-explanatory. The claim thing I could see being maybe something a newbie wouldn’t know. Again going off my own experience from when I played my first

I mean that's also really only the tip of the iceberg because even if you have an idea of what lynching and claiming is, if you're new you don't automatically make the connection that alright, I know player X's role so it doesn't really make sense for me to vote them here because it's a vote to lynch.

 

[Sky]

Very aware I'm playing into your point of bringing up old games but this reminds me of Junk last game but in reverse. You announce you've got a plan of some sort and then say something nonsensical. There's more of a logical progression so it makes me think this could easily be from a town point of view, but then I consider my view on Junk was wrong... conflicted tbh

 

[Hidden Blaze]

I mean that's also really only the tip of the iceberg because even if you have an idea of what lynching and claiming is, if you're new you don't automatically make the connection that alright, I know player X's role so it doesn't really make sense for me to vote them here because it's a vote to lynch.

That’s fair. When you put it in those words I can see what you mean. But at the same time it’s like, maybe they are just a fast learner, or lucked up and said something smart without even knowing it.

 

[Nostradamus]

I mean that's also really only the tip of the iceberg because even if you have an idea of what lynching and claiming is, if you're new you don't automatically make the connection that alright, I know player X's role so it doesn't really make sense for me to vote them here because it's a vote to lynch.

Like I said, I wanted to re-evaluate and make sure I wasn't making the wrong choice. And just because I'm new to playing the game, doesn't necessarily mean I haven't been around the block learning a few things.

 

[Tweet]

Mmmh okay I see