The Who Would Have Won Thread

[Smartmark]

This is easy, just answer the post above you and comment on why do you think your pick would have won the match. It can be anyone from history facing each other, so you can easily pick a dream match of yours. I will start, and let's remember, this is not a spam game. I would like to see some good discussions in here.


A dream match of mine that sadly never happened:


Eddie Guerrero Vs Shawn Michaels

 

[The New F'n Show]

Would go HBK in a 30 minute classic, lot of back and forth action and overselling. Sweet Chin Music finishes it. Will keep winner in it

Shawn Mchaels vs Dean Malenko.

 

[Kiffy Lube]

Well, Shawn Michaels would win and if WWE booked it probably wouldn't last 5 minutes.

British Bulldog & Owen Hart v.s Terry Gordy & Steve Williams.

 

[The New F'n Show]

Miracle Violence Connection easy

Here'a an interesting clash of styles

Gordy and Williams vs The Rockers

 

[Smartmark]

Interesting idea. Would be a nice exchange of styles, and a good midcard matchup, lasting for 15 minutes. Rockers would have won


William Regal Vs Colt Cabana

 

[PY.]

As much as I like Cabana, Regal would win this regardless of where it was booked. If the match purpose were to make Cabana look good, then it be a different story.

CM Punk vs. Shawn Michaels (If Shawn was still in wrestling today)

 

[Kiffy Lube]

Now? Michaels would probably put over Punk if a title was on the line.

Chris Jericho v.s Michael Hayes.

 

[The New F'n Show]

Jericho, Hayes was a great heel character and the build would be great but I'd go Y2J.

I'll change it up

Rockers and Jericho vs Regal, Punk and Bryan.

 

[Got_Swag]

Rockers and Jericho vs Regal, Punk and Bryan.

Depends on which Y2J and which Punk we're talking about, but I am going to go with Rockers and Y2J. The athleticism the Rockers brought to the table and Y2J's all around performance would too much for two of the best inside the ring wrestlers we've seen to date in CM Punk and Daniel Bryan

How about, Brock Lesnar versus Kevin Nash (from Wolfpack days)

 

[Heisenberg]

Brock Lesnar easily, he was much more better in the ring and could move faster. Also since he was the biggest star or one of the biggest stars before leaving.

Chris Benoit vs CM Punk?

 

[PY.]

CM Punk - If in the WWE and Punk was there during Benoit's time, I think the E would put more stock in Punk.

Kevin Nash vs. Crimson (Kevin Nash's prime booked in TNA)

 

[Smartmark]

Not a match I personally would watch if it was booked, but Nash would get the win. More stiff shots and punches and kicks than actual wrestling in this one.


Chris Benoit Vs Mike Quackenbush

 

[Got_Swag]

Easily Benoit, the younger kid would make his one crucial mistake towards the end and Benoit would lock in the crippler crossface.

Bret Hart versus Daniel Bryan

 

[Smartmark]

Interesting matchup. Bret would put over Bryan. Or, he at least should. Good technical wrestling with much mat based submissions.


Shawn Michaels Vs Sting?

 

[Got_Swag]

A dream matchup almost every fan would want to see happen. It be one hell of a battle with back and forth action. Really tough to call because I feel if HBK goes for sweet chin music then Sting can easily counter it with the Scorpion Death Drop. Then again, HBK connects it's over. Both two of the best all time and neither needing to put the other over, so I give it to HBK!

Scott Hall (in his glory days) versus The Miz