My only thoughts on this matter between the whole Gino vs Frosty thing. But Frosty, there is more than just winning matches and titles at times. Sometimes people having good promos, and characters that people get invested in is what earns people a lot of respect and attention. Gino, he's done that. He had The Blade go from a Hurricane rip-off into a somewhat serious babyface and was one of the most popular characters in the league at a time and he practically carried storylines with Sam at one point. Also, he's tried to make JSP a unique character and so far, while he ain't perfect, he's done that.
Also, he has won belts. The Blade was a world champ once or twice, as well as United States Champion, he was the first EU Champ here as (Buffalo) Bill Bronson, was IC champ as JSP, and he has been a long running member of the league.
It is not to say you haven't done well either, you have had good promos and won a lot of belts, but as the GM you should be giving people credit for what they have done, encourage them to do well and improve if they aren't at the highest level they can be yet, and take feedback yourself as that is what a leader does.
That is all. I will still be on the forum due to various reasons, but that is all for me on this conversation.