Save the Cheerleader, Save the World: Heroes Mafia Game Thread

[Odo]

Have you considered that Junk/Odo could be scum and it could benefit to bring this up? Would that change things for you?

@Odo Because I don't like admitting I may have misconstrued that post when I marked it down as him being null on him in my notes but he still wasn't really committing one way or the other so it doesn't totally fall outside of the narrative

why would admitting fault be problematic?

 

[Guts]

Jeff seems ok to me so far tbh

How so? Do you think what I brought up is outright incorrect or do you think it just isn't scummy?

 

[RDK]

Have you considered that Junk/Odo could be scum and it could benefit to bring this up? Would that change things for you?

@Odo Because I don't like admitting I may have misconstrued that post when I marked it down as him being null on him in my notes but he still wasn't really committing one way or the other so it doesn't totally fall outside of the narrative

Junk/Odo being s/s here is an interesting trail of thought

I don't have much to say about it right now though.

 

[Canadian Dragon]

chimp still no selling me

 

[Poyser]

How so? Do you think what I brought up is outright incorrect or do you think it just isn't scummy?

Uhhh I don’t really disagree there’s not been a whole lot of conviction but jeff tends to follow around a lot on D1 anyways. With him as scum I kinda look for shitty filler posts or try hard shit. Him being so actively engaged since the moment he first posted is usually a good sign for him as he does struggle early as scum to replicate the kind of post count he generates as town. I haven’t really found fault with any of his posts either so

 

[PHEN0M]

Have you considered that Junk/Odo could be scum and it could benefit to bring this up? Would that change things for you?

@Odo Because I don't like admitting I may have misconstrued that post when I marked it down as him being null on him in my notes but he still wasn't really committing one way or the other so it doesn't totally fall outside of the narrative

I think it would be foolish to not consider that sure, and it certainly can be revisited should some of those players who are involved/were around flip scum. For now, I’m taking Chris’ action at face value and believing he wouldn’t do it as scum.

 

[Poyser]

Wait why are you reading Chris town? For pointing out there could be role overlap?

not sure I follow lol

 

[Bobby Barrows]

I am really lost at the moment, but we have Junk's claim, Gambit claiming(?), and then a wagon on Jeff suddenly?

 

[Guts]

why would admitting fault be problematic?

Ultimately, I'd like a more convincing case because I do think I may have picked up on something

@Raidokken I meant one of them not both but either works. If you assume one is scum and Chris were scum with one of them then there is a benefit to bringing up the role overlap in thread

 

[Poyser]

Like that’s the kinda filler shit scum often say to look useful without actually being useful (like it’s literally in the OP) and means he doesn’t have to take any kind of stance. It’s just content

not saying he’s scum for doing it but such an odd reason to give someone a town read

 

[PHEN0M]

I’m not reading him town, i just gave him a town lean, aka i wouldn’t be interested in voting him today.

 

[Tweet]

untrue. ive stated multiple times ive liked tweet. id go as far as to say he's my strongest lead. ive said this multiple times in fact so if you are reading back, you're kind of full of shit as I can pull up posts if you'd like

Don't like this post at all. Yes Doc got that wrong but you seem to be getting pretty overdefensive and assuming ill intent instead of just correcting him and being all gucci.

 

[Laughable Chimp]

chimp still no selling me

Your question doesn't interest me.

 

[PHEN0M]

People could have easily gone on about Odo/Junk seeming to be the same role based on Odo’s early post. That’s Chris post seemingly shut that down as everyone’s like “oh yeah, it does say that, we’ll worry bout it eventually” Seems like a pro-town move imo.

 

[Canadian Dragon]

Don't like this post at all. Yes Doc got that wrong but you seem to be getting pretty overdefensive and assuming ill intent instead of just correcting him and being all gucci.

he's voting me though. I feel a defensive stance is fair here, especially when the reasoning for voting me is blantantly untrue

would you feel better about me simply no selling him?