Round 2: Quadrant 2 Matchup 2

  • Welcome to "The New" Wrestling Smarks Forum!

    I see that you are not currently registered on our forum. It only takes a second, and you can even login with your Facebook! If you would like to register now, pease click here: Register

    Once registered please introduce yourself in our introduction thread which can be found here: Introduction Board


Better World Champ?

  • Edge

    Votes: 4 26.7%
  • Undertaker

    Votes: 11 73.3%

  • Total voters
    15
  • Poll closed .

The New F'n Show

Well-Known Member
Joined
Jun 3, 2010
Messages
7,126
Reaction score
34
Points
48
Location
Detroit, Michigan, USA
Edge
edgefea.jpg

Edge won the WWE title from John Cena on January 8th 2006 at New Year’s Revolution. He lost the title back on January 29th 2006 at Royal Rumble. He won the title for a second time from Rob Van Dam on July 3rd 2006 on Raw in a triple threat match also involving John Cena. He lost the title to Cena on September 17th at Unforgiven in a TLC Match. He won the World Title from The Undertaker on the May 11th 2007 Smackdown. He vacated the title due to injury on the July 20th 2007 Smackdown. He won his second World Title from Batista on December 16th 2007 at Armageddon in a Triple Threat Match also involving the Undertaker. He lost the title to The Undertaker on March 30th 2008 at Wrestlemania. He won the vacant World Title on June 1st 2008 at One Night Stand by defeating the Undertaker in a TLC Match. He lost the title to CM Punk on June 30th 2008 on Raw. He won his third WWE title from Triple H on November 23rd 2008 at Survivor Series in a triple threat match also involving Vladimir Kozlov. He lost the title to Jeff Hardy on December 14th 2008 at Armageddon. He won the title back on January 25th 2009 at Royal Rumble in a NO DQ match. He lost the title to Triple H on February 15th 2009 at No Way Out in an Elimination Chamber match also involving Jeff Hardy, Vladimir Kozlov, The Undertaker and The Big Show. He won his fourth World Title from John Cena on February 15th 2009 at No Way Out in an Elimination Chamber match also involving Chris Jericho, Rey Mysterio, Mike Knox, and Kane. He lost the title to John Cena in a triple threat match also involving Big Show on April 5th 2009 at Wrestlemania. He won the title back in a Last Man Standing Match on April 26th 2009 at Backlash. He lost the title to Jegg Hardy in a Ladder Match on June 7th 2009 at Extreme Rules. He won his sixth World Title from Kane in a Four Way TLC Match also involving Rey Mysterio and Alberto Del Rio at TLC on December 19th 2010. He was stripped of the Title for using the Spear on the February 18th 2011 Smackdown. He won the title back from newly crowned champion Dolph Ziggler that same night. He vacated the title due to retirement on The April 12th 2011 Smackdown.

Undertaker
undertaker%20champion.jpg

The Undertaker won the WWE title from Hulk Hogan on November 27th 1991 at Survivor Series. He lost the title back on December 3rd 1991 at This Tuesday in Texas. He won his second WWE title from Sycho Sid on March 23rd 1997 at Wrestlemania. He lost the title to Bret Hart on August 3rd 1997 at Summerslam in a match featuring Shawn Michaels as referee. He won his third WWE title from Steve Austin on May 23rd 1999 at Over the Edge with The McMahons as referees. He lost the title back to Austin on June 28th 1999 on Raw. He won his fourth WWE title from Hulk Hogan on May 19th 2002 at Judgment Day. He lost the title to The Rock in a triple threat match also involving Kurt Angle on July 21st 2002 at Vengeance. He won the World title from Batista on April 1st 2007 at Wrestlemania. He lost the title to Edge on the May 11th 2007 Smackdown. He won the title back on March 30th 2008 at Wrestlemania. He vacated the title due to his Hell’s Gate finisher being banned on the May 2nd 2008 Smackdown. He won his third world title from CM Punk on October 4th 2009 at Hell in a Cell in a Hell in a Cell Match. He lost the title to Chris Jericho on February 21st 2010 at Elimination Chamber in an Elimination Chamber match also involving John Morrison, R-Truth, CM Punk, and Rey Mysterio.
 

TheZig

Member
Joined
Jun 1, 2011
Messages
618
Reaction score
3
Points
18
Age
32
This was a tough call for me, But the presence of Taker as champion made me pick him. Ofcourse Edge had many good matches as champion but alot of his reigns were lackluster.
 

PHX

Legacy Member
Joined
Dec 3, 2010
Messages
23,705
Reaction score
402
Points
83
Age
36
Location
Phoenix, AZ
Favorite Wrestler
cmpunk2
Favorite Wrestler
adamcole2
Favorite Wrestler
ajstyles2
Favorite Wrestler
braywyatt
Favorite Wrestler
dx
Favorite Wrestler
samoajoe
Favorite Sports Team
n1QhWSb
Favorite Sports Team
osX2DVG
This is the hardest one yet but went with Taker. About half of Edge's reigns didn't do much for me.
 

Kiffy Lube

Girls Just Wanna Have Fun
Joined
Jun 25, 2011
Messages
80,150
Reaction score
13,528
Points
248
Age
35
Location
The Large House, Arizona
Favorite Wrestler
lowki
Favorite Wrestler
lowki
Favorite Wrestler
lowki
Favorite Wrestler
lowki
Favorite Wrestler
lowki
Favorite Wrestler
lowki
Fuck Edge's title reigns especially compared to Taker who has actual meaningful reigns.
 

Keith

WCW Halloween Phantom
Joined
Aug 6, 2010
Messages
16,736
Reaction score
3,010
Points
113
Tough call. I see what people mean by Takers reigns meaning something and maybe because he had less they do stand out more. However Edge did draw great heat as champion and the reason I picked him was because the title didn't really mean that much to Taker, the character had gotten over with out it, and you don't think of him and the world title. But Edge wearing it was a big deal and brought credibility to it, epsically when he first won it.
 

Deuce

Well-Known Member
Joined
Nov 17, 2011
Messages
3,151
Reaction score
35
Points
48
Location
Canada
Undertaker was the better champ, I like Edge and all but Taker's reigns were more intimidating and BEAST.
 

Andrew

Well-Known Member
Joined
Jun 3, 2010
Messages
18,926
Reaction score
364
Points
83
Age
36
Location
Geelong, Australia
Favorite Wrestler
chrisbenoit2
Favorite Wrestler
princedevitt
Favorite Wrestler
sethrollins
Favorite Wrestler
ajstyles2
Favorite Wrestler
johncena2
Favorite Wrestler
ricochet
I like Edge so I went with him
 

Kingslayer

Member
Joined
Dec 4, 2010
Messages
724
Reaction score
12
Points
18
Location
Kings Landing, Crownlands, Westeros
Favorite Wrestler
stonecold2
Favorite Wrestler
jbl2
Favorite Wrestler
cmpunk2
Favorite Wrestler
damiensandow
Favorite Wrestler
braywyatt
Favorite Wrestler
wadebarrett
Fuck Edge, he ruined the title. 11 world titles in 5 years? Whoever pitched that should be shot.

Taker is better than Edge regardless. Taker.
 

Troy

Well-Known Member
Joined
May 11, 2010
Messages
23,057
Reaction score
72
Points
48
Location
Streets Ahead
Favorite Wrestler
wherestroy
Favorite Wrestler
wherestroy
Favorite Wrestler
wherestroy
Favorite Wrestler
wherestroy
Favorite Wrestler
wherestroy
Favorite Wrestler
wherestroy
This is tough. Both are right up there as top champions and it is a shame they face each other so soon. I went with Undertaker because when he holds the title it means a lot more.
 

Keith

WCW Halloween Phantom
Joined
Aug 6, 2010
Messages
16,736
Reaction score
3,010
Points
113
Fuck Edge, he ruined the title. 11 world titles in 5 years? Whoever pitched that should be shot.

Taker is better than Edge regardless. Taker.
But you can't blame Edge for WWE's shitty booking. Fact is he made the best he could out of it, and got over despite it. And when he first won the belt as the rated R Superstar and ended that tedious Cena reign it was a massive deal.

Also I disagree looking at Edge's career compared with Taker, Edge was consistant all the why though, where as Taker didn't really get going until about 97 and even then was carried by the likes of Bret Hart, Mankind and Shawn Michaels. His later career has been much better.
 

Kingslayer

Member
Joined
Dec 4, 2010
Messages
724
Reaction score
12
Points
18
Location
Kings Landing, Crownlands, Westeros
Favorite Wrestler
stonecold2
Favorite Wrestler
jbl2
Favorite Wrestler
cmpunk2
Favorite Wrestler
damiensandow
Favorite Wrestler
braywyatt
Favorite Wrestler
wadebarrett
Why do I care if "he made the best he could out of it"? It still happened on his watch, isn't it? Aren't we comparing champions here? Well, Edge was an awful champion. It doesn't matter if he's at fault or not.

The bit about Edge being better than Undertaker is too ridiculous for me to even know where to begin.