Round 1: Quadrant 1 Matchup 5

[The New F'n Show]

Alberto Del Rio

Big Show/Giant

 

[Brock Lesnar]

Voted for Big Show. He's had some memorable runs, throughout the years. Del Rio isn't that good, I never liked him as a worker. He's got the same material, over and over again. He hasn't even been around that long either. Show had a bunch of title runs as a heel, he's been the focal point of Wrestlemania a bunch of times as a heel.

 

[The New F'n Show]

Dug The Giant when he first debuted and Show had some solid moments. Del Rio is too repetitive I agree. Show for me, but not by that much.

 

[Lewb]

I've never enjoyed Big Show as a heel. Del Rio came about at the right time I believe so I'm giving Del Rio the nod.

 

[Keith]

This is a tough one. Never been a big Show fan, but like Scott did enjoy his early WCW run and just because of how new Del Rio still is, and his mixed results so far, I think Show edges this one.

 

[Deuce]

Going with ADR, seems like a better Heel to me.

 

[Kiffy Lube]

Going to be openly biased and choose ADR.

 

[Andrew]

Voted Big Show here, I felt Big Show plays a heel better then Del Rio.

Del Rio doesn't get as much reaction compared to Big Show.

 

[#HEEL]

Whos making theses matchups? It HAS to be Show between the two, Del Rio hasnt been around long enough to even be in the conversation, and even if he had been the guy gets no reaction.

 

[PHX]

Del Rio has no business being in this. Can't pick a heel who can't even get heat. Big Show.

 

[Canadian Pothead]

Big Show for me, if just deciding it on his run as The Giant in WCW. Nothing against Alberto Del Rio, but I feel he needs more time to make his persona more well rounded.

 

[Smartmark]

Big Show gets my vote

 

[Darth Shizzel]

Big Show definatey Del Rio should change his name to Alberto Bor Rio

 

[Crippler]

Big Show's 03 smackdown heel work shits on everything ADR has done to this point, and I don't even have to bring up the ECW 06 stuff show did.

 

[Vita]

The one and only time Big Show was a credible heel was when he was represented by Paul Heyman and facing Brock Lesnar, the biggest star in the world at the time. Big Show is an AWFUL heel, Del Rio should win by default.