Romance of the Three Kingdoms Mafia - Game Thread

[Mitch Buchannon]

Hey guys I’m at work so I won’t be very active until later


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[Barry Poppins]

Ol

We're not blind lynching anyone.

Just use investigate roles on people that can't be read and are likely to make end game.

And we are playing mafia are we not sky? If the op tells me we're not I'll consider reading it.

This would be great! And I would agree.....

If Smark hadn't already claimed the caveat and therefore made that possibility null and void

In fairness to Smark, what else would he do if he was forced to claim? It's better that it's out in the open now instead of when the pressure is on him, because claiming that is a one-way ticket to a lynch.

 

[Sky]

We're not blind lynching anyone.

Just use investigate roles on people that can't be read and are likely to make end game.

And we are playing mafia are we not sky? If the op tells me we're not I'll consider reading it.

We're playing Mafia that is not only multiscum, but multitown, and info is scattered among players who can't claim it, and there are players who can't claim things about their alignment lest they be punished

 

[RDK]

Ol


In fairness to Smark, what else would he do if he was forced to claim? It's better that it's out in the open now instead of when the pressure is on him, because claiming that is a one-way ticket to a lynch.

So you're saying it is a town utility role that should be used in a certain circumstance where it is hidden in order to catch a scum quick lynch, but you're also saying that it should be claimed immediately thus making your first point an impossibility?

 

[Ricky Smarks]

This would be great! And I would agree.....

If Smark hadn't already claimed the caveat and therefore made that possibility null and void

How I decide to play doesn't change the host's intended utility.

 

[Showtime]

Personally I don't get it.

I see his role as a town utility role. It can be used if Smark is caught in MyLo to catch scum in a quick vote situation, so I don't see why Haza exactly wants to lynch Smark.

His reasoning is flawed as Smark played everybody with his play last game as scum so I doubt Smark is gonna easily lapse into his scum meta after last game.

So are you not suss of haza then?

 

[Ricky Smarks]

So you're saying it is a town utility role that should be used in a certain circumstance where it is hidden in order to catch a scum quick lynch, but you're also saying that it should be claimed immediately thus making your first point an impossibility?

That's gist of it. The role says I can choose when to vote with one and two votes.

However, knowing you guys if I even tried to whip out a double vote later in the game you'd want to lynch me immediately.

 

[Showtime]

We're playing Mafia that is not only multiscum, but multitown, and info is scattered among players who can't claim it, and there are players who can't claim things about their alignment lest they be punished

ok so basically a bunch of stuff that cant be mentioned.

wow im so disappointed i didnt read that, such crucial info.

 

[RDK]

That's gist of it. The role says I can choose when to vote with one and two votes.

However, knowing you guys if I even tried to whip out a double vote later in the game you'd want to lynch me immediately.

I really don't think so. Especially with the tinkered caveat that is provable I think it leaves you in the same spot you are in now. Especially given that you'd have legitimate reasons for keeping it hidden that me and Barry have just discussed.

 

[Barry Poppins]

So you're saying it is a town utility role that should be used in a certain circumstance where it is hidden in order to catch a scum quick lynch, but you're also saying that it should be claimed immediately thus making your first point an impossibility?

"So you're saying" arguments wildly misrepresent what is said. If Smark is in MyLo, he can use it to weed out potential scum by virtue of his vote. That doesn't mean he has to keep it hidden. It forces scum to have to play to Smark's terms in MyLo. It's highly doubtful Smark makes it to end game so it's all moot.

 

[Comrade Khan]

"So you're saying" arguments wildly misrepresent what is said. If Smark is in MyLo, he can use it to weed out potential scum by virtue of his vote. That doesn't mean he has to keep it hidden. It forces scum to have to play to Smark's terms in MyLo. It's highly doubtful Smark makes it to end game so it's all moot.

wtf is a MYLO

 

[Barry Poppins]

So are you not suss of haza then?

Are you suspect of him?

 

[Sky]

ok so basically a bunch of stuff that cant be mentioned.

wow im so disappointed i didnt read that, such crucial info.

The fact that you didn't read the OP despite being told to read the OP tells me that you weren't expecting to see anything special in it and hence didn't need to read it. I wonder why? Maybe it's because there's another possible source of information about the state of the game, maybe one you received in your role PM?

The fact that you're trying to play this off as still not caring makes it worse.

 

[Barry Poppins]

wtf is a MYLO

Mislynch and lose. Different from Lynch and Lose in that LyLo is if we mislynch, we still have a chance of making it to next day if shit goes poorly for scum. MyLo is we lose that day if we fuck up.

 

[RDK]

Everyone i'm going to go MEDITATE. Hopefully that chills me out per Barry's request. Keep fighting for the SHOE kingdom my fellow shoers