Prey At Night: The Strangers Mafia Game Thread

[Sky]

Its about feel.

Okay that confirms to me you have literally zero reads

 

[CakeWalker]

The biggest issue is that Blaine hasn't cleared Cake, only made it so her lynch today isn't a viable option atm. Blaine could be lying for a multitude of reasons. He could be town too, like I've been leaning him on. The point is, we have a role that's janitored, a player who willingly divulged information about an hour or so after the night flip.

There's still scenarios where Blaine could be town and Cake could be scum. But that's far less likely than the other way around.

If Blaine is town. Then I can't have a killing action. There is no scenario in which he flips town and I don't. From Blaine's pov I'm confirmed to not have a killing action ergo not scum, not sk and not any town role with an active killing ability like a vig etc.

 

[Polar Bear]

Sky is caught in the classic loop of trying to defend against the insane which is of itself insane but it shows that she wants to defend being called scum, bc she is one. Definitely putting her up at the top

 

[Bobby Barrows]

If Blaine is town. Then I can't have a killing action. There is no scenario in which he flips town and I don't. From Blaine's pov I'm confirmed to not have a killing action ergo not scum, not sk and not any town role with an active killing ability like a vig etc.

Uhhhhhhh yes there is? Redirecting roles?

Why they would target Blaine, I don't know. That's a different question entirely.

The point is you're grasping at straws trying to find any excuse to deny the *plausibility* of such a scenario being the case.

 

[CakeWalker]

Pushing this hard, is a big mafia tell or just you've got a crush on me lol

 

[Bobby Barrows]

Pushing this hard, is a big mafia tell or just you've got a crush on me lol

I'm not even pushing you lol. I'm pointing out that you aren't cleared just because Blaine says you can't kill, right after a role was janitored. Blaine isn't 100% town at this moment, which is what it feels like you have a hard time grasping rn.

 

[Sky]

Sky is caught in the classic loop of trying to defend against the insane which is of itself insane but it shows that she wants to defend being called scum, bc she is one. Definitely putting her up at the top

uh.... what? I'm just trying to establish whether you have actual reads or are just making shit up. I've gotten my answer

 

[CakeWalker]

Until Blaine is proven to not be town, I am clear. 1+1 = 2

 

[Bobby Barrows]

Unless Blaine is confirmed town, his info should be taken into consideration but not taken as gospel.

 

[Bobby Barrows]

Until Blaine is proven to not be town, I am clear. 1+1 = 2

You are not clear lol, you're just not the ideal lynch today anymore.

 

[Bobby Barrows]

Can we get more votes on OMB already, Chriminy.

 

[CakeWalker]

I am more clear than anyone else in the game lol

 

[Bobby Barrows]

I am more clear than anyone else in the game lol

Whatever you tell yourself, mate.

 

[CakeWalker]

Evans / Barry / Lethal?

I could see it. Sky just sounds annoyed for some reason, not sure what.

 

[Sky]

Let's look at the permutations

Blaine town, Cake town = seemingly the simplest explanation but 100% not confirmed and certain people should not be acting like it is. On in-thread play I have serious doubts
Blaine town, Cake scum = impossible
Blaine scum, Cake town = an attempt by scum Blaine to claim a legit result and gain town points
Biaine scum, Cake scum = teammates hunkering down and congealing as split begins to favour them