I agree with your last sentence only, pyro.
The fact is Gerwitz is a lazy fuck. He can coast, throw out pointless comedy bits that aren't funny, not book long matches, and stretch segments out too long. However, when it comes down to it he can flip a switch and make compelling TV and characters.
He can make a feud like HHH vs Orton when it just began. He can make characters like The Animal, The Legend Killer/Viper, Super Cena, The Game, Rated R Superstar, Captain Charisma, The Rock, Casper, and so on. He can create stables like Evolution, Legacy, and Nexus. He just is the better writer.
I mean can anyone name the last great stable that Hayes made, the last great mainstay main eventer he created, or a stable/team to remember?