Norse Mythology Mafia - Game Thread

[Roy Mustang]

Might have been a suggestion to get a wagon going on him, maybe he didn't know that this post would be explored later on?

Now that's more likely. Him shooting Magic night 1? Nah. Him subtly trying to get Magic lynched? Much more likely

 

[Evans]

tbf the wording was not that. he wanted a flip, not a lynch

I think you got to earn your town clout again too btw, your past town reads are swell though since they include me

Do you think CP backs off the Magic lynch as he did, just to shoot Magic at night instead?

The lynch on Magic prior to Haza was at 50% and considering how quickly Haza's wagon developed, do you think that Magic was unlikely to get lynched D1 even if CP hadn't unvoted when he did?

 

[PHEN0M]

Scared coward Poyser, ducking the heat. (All seriousness, hope he’s good.)

Vote: Magic

 

[Chloe B]

Do you think CP backs off the Magic lynch as he did, just to shoot Magic at night instead?

The lynch on Magic prior to Haza was at 50% and considering how quickly Haza's wagon developed, do you think that Magic was unlikely to get lynched D1 even if CP hadn't unvoted when he did?

I don't remember the Magic wagon being that hot, besides he got out of it didn't he

If you want Magic gone you try in the thread first, then at night, simple

 

[Chloe B]

Now that's more likely. Him shooting Magic night 1? Nah. Him subtly trying to get Magic lynched? Much more likely

may not have even been his decision

 

[Roy Mustang]

may not have even been his decision

That is possible but I feel like we should focus on the post from another angle to see if he is scum. The night kill could have also been Indy or a vig as I would presume we are missing a kill somewhere based on OMB's split

 

[Evans]

I don't remember the Magic wagon being that hot, besides he got out of it didn't he

If you want Magic gone you try in the thread first, then at night, simple

Nah you're right, he was at 3 not 6. I even quoted the vote counts

I'm gonna read back on CP but right now, I think it's unlikely CP makes a play that outs him like that if he is scum.

 

[Chloe B]

It's just a thought anyway

I like wagon analysis better

 

[Chloe B]

Nah you're right, he was at 3 not 6. I even quoted the vote counts

I'm gonna read back on CP but right now, I think it's unlikely CP makes a play that outs him like that if he is scum.

Do you think he'd remember a throwaway post like that well after he made it?

 

[PHEN0M]

CP would 100% be so bold to say something like that about magic if was scum and his team killed him. He loves WIFOM. It’s like when i do the <B>Actions final</B> post

 

[Showtime]

You think Lethal shoots him after reaffirming his suspicion earlier on today?





The bolded makes me wonder if this was a hint to something looking back on it now?

I'm not sure why Lethal if he's scum is playing an awkward, almost shy game but then shoots the only person he's really sussed out openly in the thread. Do you think that adds up?

I'm for this direction, just trying to see the reasoning.

lethal, no offense to lethal, wouldnt likely have as much sway in who gets shot as opposed to cp


altho cp sometimes opts out but he seems pretty involved in this game.

 

[Evans]

Do you think he'd remember a throwaway post like that well after he made it?

Eh, very WIFOM. I wouldn't necessarily call it throwaway either. He was justifying his reasoning prior to his vote if you look at the entire picture.

idk who I wanna lynch nobody really jumping out at me today

If y'all could flip someone rn who would it be and why? I'd say Magic because his read on Haza felt like BS and he makes a big deal about town reading as many people as he can but he hasn't done a lot of that and also isn't doing anything else

vote Magic

Not going to make it to PAL-halla with that attitude

we're not gonna have a case on anyone today lol

He hasn't really turned up as town in a long time so I'm not bothered

But, what caught my eye Chloe was this post, reminding us about Magic and his reasons for sussing him. The last line feels very 'final'.

Anyway I still think Magic's town read on Haza was way too generous and he could be scum. Just didn't feel like lynching him day 1 since if he's town he'll be a big asset. But yeah don't let him coast on just throwing out some weak town reads here and there or barely pushing a direction while letting town destroy itself

Although @CraigPelton re this post:

I explained all of that when Smark asked about it

You didn't explain why you felt Haza was better than the no-lynch you said that would be best? You even added your defence about you & Haza possibly sharing a vibe?

It's also possible Haza and I just got the same VIBE

nah I had some minor suspicion that he may be trying to pocket me as he likes to do

I was fine with a no lynch as I stated

OMB didn't have the votes or momentum sadly. Also others brought up a good point that we'd be able to solve him anyway

 

[Evans]

lethal, no offense to lethal, wouldnt likely have as much sway in who gets shot as opposed to cp


altho cp sometimes opts out but he seems pretty involved in this game.

Yeah that makes sense.

What do you think about the post from CP saying he'd want your flip, do you think it's as telling as Chloe suggests?

 

[Tweet]

I agree CP saying he's sus of Magic only to then shoot him is a weird move, it's pretty WIFOMy tho, I don't even wanna go down that rabbit hole. I got no complaints with him outside that either so I don't see myself looking that direction anytime soon

vote Lethal

 

[TKOK]

maybe scum are scared cowards?