No More Happy Endings - Once Upon a Time Mafia Game Thread

[Grim]

Me

That's what I figured.

Vote: John

 

[John McHenry]

I mean, misremembering stuff isn't AI, isn't it?

It's becoming a lot.

 

[Tommy Bedlam]

I do think overall John is the best shot nonetheless, and that being said his lynch could help us potentially read Ekko and a few others too.

Was it John or Lethal actually who had a weird read of Ekko based on just his few posts?

So are you gonna vote for John in practice instead of spirit? We’re quite a ways off from 10 from what I can tell.

John said something weird about Ekko. Phenom actually put a vote down, which is also something I think we will need to look into.

 

[John McHenry]

I shall fall on my sword apparently sussing Ekko and changing a vote is far too damn waste of a power

 

[Mandalorian]

On the plus side, I got you and Tommy firmly town atm. You're both leading and trying to figure out a reason as to the why and connect the dots. I don't really discount that I look bad, but I personally don't care that I do. However I do think it can be said we still could get something good out of it all even if I end up dying or lynched or what have you.

The indy talk though is not really helpful and indy-spec tends to lend itself to a mafia tactic to push someone without saying they're "mafia". You know what I mean?

I do think overall John is the best shot nonetheless, and that being said his lynch could help us potentially read Ekko and a few others too.

I am with you on the indy stuff, but given the specific circumstances and your initial reaction to the fallout from you killing Pein, I think it’s a valid question to ask. However, both myself and Tommy first thought that it was done out of a need to steer people away from McHenry and that it’s more likely you were mafia with him than an indy out of those two options.

Are you going to put your vote there? I’m not trying to force you, but you’ve said a few times now that’s where we should go but you’ve not yet backed it up with the vote.

 

[Tommy Bedlam]

I'm starting to wonder about Tommy myself lot of mis remembering and inferring coming from him.

I'm gone for a bit if not the night.

And he does it again. Heat on John, John talks about me. I misspoke about your non vote on Ekko. You’re grasping, which is classic scum play.

 

[Tommy Bedlam]

That's what I figured.

Vote: John

Ignore my last question to you

 

[Comrade Khan]

On face value , even as indie , i think makes even less sense for grim? Like he just put a gigantic target on his back if hes not lynched? Or scum would push him hard now to lynch. Like zero value to do this as indie. Think im burrying that possibility

 

[Sister Abigail]

The question is who was suspicious of Barry first

I think it was me. I don't think Lethal ever said he sussed Barry, just that he vibed with my read list. Not sure when Juice started sussing Barry but I think that's interesting because early on in the game there's a moment where Barry does defend Juice (despite Barry saying 'in fear of seemingly defending Juice). Curious if Juice's scum read on Barry might have been developed or influenced by that.

 

[Grim]

So are you gonna vote for John in practice instead of spirit? We’re quite a ways off from 10 from what I can tell.

John said something weird about Ekko. Phenom actually put a vote down, which is also something I think we will need to look into.

Ah fuck can't forget about N0M either but if I can play a bit of WIFOM I don't think scum N0M votes Ekko if scum John is talking about him.

 

[Tommy Bedlam]

I shall fall on my sword apparently sussing Ekko and changing a vote is far too damn waste of a power

Just add this to my list of posts I don’t like. The attempt to divert attention to me, and then A decree that he’s “falling on his sword” for changing a vote.

 

[Ekkologix]

Also no one has accused anyone of being toxic yet

agree. idk what jeff is on about

 

[Comrade Khan]

Also u may not like my more chill approach but my wagon still leading so i think im doing perfectly ok at "leading"

 

[Comrade Khan]

agree. idk what jeff is on about

Shes on my side...lol

 

[Mandalorian]

I shall fall on my sword apparently sussing Ekko and changing a vote is far too damn waste of a power

This is not what it solely comes down to at all. You said you wanted to go for Ekko because he was the easy option due to his inactivity, no?

Your reads lists was broadly a set of comments on your experiences with players in previous games and very little about this game. It came across as you were trying to give opinions but most of it was irrelevant as there wasn’t even much talk over how your past experiences with the players you mentioned informed your views on them in this game; whether they were acting similar or different and what that meant.