No More Happy Endings - Once Upon a Time Mafia Game Thread

[Tommy Bedlam]

To add to this, when McHenry first checked in there was like four posts in the thread and one of those was your vote for Shade.

I am aware that in isolation is not much, and he could just have gotten his wires crossed, but at the time of his first post I’d have expected him to know where your vote actually was.

To add to this, I think it's slightly alarming that McHenry talked about voting Ekko, then backed off. Then threw a vote on Pendex. Then, in a little less than an hour (I think), dropped that vote and shifted a vote to Sky.

 

[CakeWalker]

You were calling me childish before you made post #821.

You're timeline now doesn't add up. This is inherently scummy.

 

[CakeWalker]

That looks like a major slip to me.

 

[Mandalorian]

@Sister Abigail what are your thoughts on Jeff? Still scum reading him?

@Tommy Bedlam the first question for you as well.

 

[Lethal]

I also got past Juice's dossiers and there's not really much to say from them here. Two of them are for Tommy and Mando who are fairly widespread and popular town reads so they feel like empty words. Even I, the one you're sussing most (probably for OMGUS reasons), am just a neutral. Therefore I see them as just a way to look active and insightful when you're coming under pressure

I like this post.

I had a town lean o Sky, and a Scum read on Jeff. When I was Jeff lean into a defence of Sky, I thought "hmm, maybe he is doing this as scum to look good down the line". It's not really important by itself.

You, then, went straight to "he is white knighting". That to me felt like the possibility of him attempting to buddy Sky didn't really come into it for you, so I wondered as to why that could be. Specifically, I was looking for an explanation from you as to why you went straight to it being white knighting and not, say, scum buddying.

Does that make sense? You'll note - in my quote wall, I didn't bring up the buddying as a point against Jeff specifically at all.

Yup, that makes sense. I went to white knighting cos he leapt to her defense for something I believed was not game related, so considering alignment was never in my calculations there

 

[Mandalorian]

To add to this, I think it's slightly alarming that McHenry talked about voting Ekko, then backed off. Then threw a vote on Pendex. Then, in a little less than an hour (I think), dropped that vote and shifted a vote to Sky.

Yeah I didn’t like the pushing of Ekko, especially when there are players in the game who have contributed just as little as him (Phenom and Baldrick).

It seemed to me that he saw Ekko as the easy lynch until he encountered some resistance to it.

 

[Sky]

You were calling me childish before you made post #821.

You're timeline now doesn't add up. This is inherently scummy.

[citation needed]

 

[Lethal]

You were calling me childish before you made post #821.

You're timeline now doesn't add up. This is inherently scummy.

Fabrication for life. I've been over this ad nauseum

That looks like a major slip to me.

Aw you're gonna suss me cos I'm sussing you. Just like with Sky. Cute.

 

[CakeWalker]

If you are claiming post #821 - is the content I was asking for.

That is after you started insulting me.

If it was the quote about T-Pein - that I called lazy. Then I stand my viewpoint it was lazy.

I never sussed Sky - Sky is a neutral read. Poorly executed attempt there on my Sky read though

 

[Pendex]

I like this post.

Yup, that makes sense. I went to white knighting cos he leapt to her defense for something I believed was not game related, so considering alignment was never in my calculations there

Fair. And to be clear - my contention was never "this must be TMI". It was a "hmm, maybe this could be TMI", I just wanted the reasoning behind it.

 

[CakeWalker]

And the difference is - I actually understand Sky's reasoning. Although I don't agree with it.

 

[Tommy Bedlam]

@Tommy Bedlam the first question for you as well.

I'm still riding kind of null on Jeff, but I also don't know his game all that well. He seems to be trying to shut down the fighting between Lethal and Juice, which is a good thing IMO. Gun to head, I may lean the slightest bit scum, but there are people I'm far more interested in than him right now.

 

[Sky]

I asked a very simple question and got met with attitude that I perceive as childish. If this is aggressive then...wow.

Do not buck against Juice because it's aggressive and you cannot ask any questions. Noted.

To be fair you had unnecessary aggression previously, it's not just a Juice issue

 

[Pendex]

On the note of Jeff, I don't have a particularly strong read there. To be honest I am thinking I need to look for townies instead, later tonight I will put a reads list together from what I have.

 

[Sister Abigail]

But I'm not getting down an annoying, fruitless rabbit hole with a player who refuses to play nice with others.

@Sister Abigail hope you get some updated reads fella

Updated reads? I dropped a reads list before I went to sleep last night and I'm only ten pages behind.