Nintendo Mafia - Game Thread

[Comrade Khan]

not to mention she's vanished since, which is another general tell, doesn't seem to be fighting her lynch all that much. idk, all signs point to scum sky. only thing obviously making me scared is the claim, but that's normal.

 

[Chris]

I never really shook her original weird play on Rugrat either tbh, she's done nothing to make me believe she's town this game.

 

[RDK]

not to mention she's vanished since, which is another general tell, doesn't seem to be fighting her lynch all that much. idk, all signs point to scum sky. only thing obviously making me scared is the claim, but that's normal.

I think skys claim is legit and probably town.

 

[RDK]

Sky is the lynch here if we are worried about her role becoming a problem late in game but I'm pretty sure her role is legit and likely town

 

[Lethal]

not to mention she's vanished since, which is another general tell, doesn't seem to be fighting her lynch all that much. idk, all signs point to scum sky. only thing obviously making me scared is the claim, but that's normal.

Yup, the claim is what holds me back too.

Looking back at the start of the game, she was going ham on Rugrat:

Do you also think a page 1 vote, even if it's justified in some way, is a serious attempt at scum hunting? Complete dullard of a player, I swear

All started from a vote on Chris, ftr.

 

[Big Man]

@Big Man can you tell me why I should choose OMB over Sky ? In non-Rick & Morty-esque words please

Day 1: OMB says he feels good about one of Chris/Barry being scum. has Chris in his scum list but not Barry but reiterates one of them is scum. Barry then flips town so you'd think he'd be pretty set on Chris being scum.

Night 1: I send a note to OMB claiming to be Chris and the survivor and not to push me and I'll OMGUS anyone who pushes me. I also said I know the message is going to a random scum player who's identity I don't know.

Day 2: OMB comes in and immediately says he might have been wrong about Chris. so he's willing to let a non-town player live and keep the information to himself and also seems to be afraid of the OMGUS threat. he then says 'chris I expect you to put 1 and 1 together here' which indicates to me that he believes the note came from Chris. if he believes the validity of the note and he read it properly then the bit where I said it's going to a random scum player basically has to be true.

that's pretty much the gist of it.

 

[Alco]

Day 1: OMB says he feels good about one of Chris/Barry being scum. has Chris in his scum list but not Barry but reiterates one of them is scum. Barry then flips town so you'd think he'd be pretty set on Chris being scum.

Night 1: I send a note to OMB claiming to be Chris and the survivor and not to push me and I'll OMGUS anyone who pushes me. I also said I know the message is going to a random scum player who's identity I don't know.

Day 2: OMB comes in and immediately says he might have been wrong about Chris. so he's willing to let a non-town player live and keep the information to himself and also seems to be afraid of the OMGUS threat. he then says 'chris I expect you to put 1 and 1 together here' which indicates to me that he believes the note came from Chris. if he believes the validity of the note and he read it properly then the bit where I said it's going to a random scum player basically has to be true.

that's pretty much the gist of it.

God damn.

 

[Alco]

Yeah I think given the info now

Raidooken, Gambitto, Jeffatron, Rugrat

Sky

Chris, Big Man, Mitch, Tweetums,

Phenom & the rest idk.

This doesn't look fantastic either, btw. He's town-reading a (in his mind) claimed survivor and the one who goes all-in on him

His top-sus Haza is basically OMGUS. --> this annoys me, because I'm not exactly a fan of Haza either.

 

[Comrade Khan]

to be fair to OMB, however, it's still somewhat believable he simply backed off chris due to his result from tracker (assuming he's being truthful, obvi) and fell into your trap anyways. I think we need to consider the player i nquestion is also not someone who plays standardly, so I still see an off chance he COULD be town.

 

[Alco]

the potential saving grace for OMB is that he actually targeted his top scum read, at least. Again, like you said, Jeff, if we're to believe him.

 

[Chris]

If he truly believed I didn't send the note the whole time I think that makes sense for why he cleared me if you combine that with his tracker shot, but his first few posts towards me at the beginning of the phase make me question if he thought the note was fake or from me

 

[Alco]

Jeff, btw, who's your vote actually on? Cause in the vote-count it's on both Sky and OMB

 

[Big Man]

to be fair to OMB, however, it's still somewhat believable he simply backed off chris due to his result from tracker (assuming he's being truthful, obvi) and fell into your trap anyways. I think we need to consider the player i nquestion is also not someone who plays standardly, so I still see an off chance he COULD be town.

the thing is Chris asked him why he's flipping his read and he replied 'I think you know more about that than me' so he was saying he's backing off due to the note when hinting at the info instead would've made a lot more sense. I do agree there is a slight chance he could be town because he is very random. if it most other players in this position I'd say they're 100% scum but I'm still pretty confident here.

 

[Rugrat]

Big Man with a 140 IQ gambit

I bet he watches Rick and Morty

 

[Lethal]

Vote: OMB

Earlier I said gun to my head I'd go Skybox, but I'm putting my trust in Big Man