Your talking about a past 5 years that has all but ignored the midcard, so being among the best isn't a huge accomplishment. Besides, you forgot Matt Hardy, Jeff Hardy, CM Punk, Bobby Lashley, and Santino Marella -- they have all been more popular faces than MVP within the last 5 years.
I meant currently on the roster. The only face on the roster is Santino, and he's not as over as MVP. As far as mid card not being a huge accomplishment... sure. But i do think he was the best, or one of the best in the mid card over the past 5 years. So i consider that makes him have a successful career. Being a WWE television 4 years, just about every week. I think he can look back, and feel like accomplished something, even though he never won the championship.
Monty: There's something to be said for WWE screwing him and holding him back, but still that drove him to the point of not caring anymore. (I know i've said similar things before about, Shelton in WWE, and I was a big fan.) And nobody's arguing it's harder to be face than heel, but MVP was just out there to be out there, face, heel or otherwise. His matches were decent and promos the same. Whether he was horribly booked, which I agree he was by the time the losing streak came around, is irrelevant to his performances. I would also debate whether he went over above and beyond what they wanted from him. He had a rep for complaining about everything, as well as again, I haven't seen any matches or promos from him since the Matt feud to be deserving of being considered "The biggest dropped ball of the decade" or anything like that. Not to mention Edge and Show are more over on a weekly basis, MVP gets pops some weeks, some weeks not. Come on, man, do you really think he's on the same level with Cena or Rey?
Not the same level, i meant MVP was behind those guys in popularity. I don't think MVP was the biggest ball drop by any means. I just didnt like how you worded him being lazy and not caring, and all the fault on was MVP. I guess that was the biggest disagreement we have. I just think he went out there, and did what they asked. They weren't looking for him to steal the show with 20 minute matches anymore. They were using him as a veteran face, to get young heels over. ( Ex. Miz, CM Punk, Jack Swagger, Alberto Del Rio, Drew Mcintyre, Cody Rhodes) I feel he did that, and did it fairly well. I've always enjoyed his promos, which are harder for a face, but then again, it often depends on the WWE putting him in a meaningful fued, to really generate a great promo. I think it would be hard to say MVP doesn't have good mic skills.
Edge has had multiple failed face runs. Big Show is just out there. I don't recall the fans ever chanting for big show, although i'm sure that have in a rare occasion. I did really like the SHow/Swagger feud though.
But in the end, you have a good point, maybe things would be different if he was booked better. But honestly, I don't think so. Lazy, unmotivated, jaded, it's all pretty much the same. MVP's talent isn't worthy of having a funeral over, when as mentioned before, there have been guys that were capable of great matches and were cut off before they even had the chance to get over that people think nothing of. MVP wasn't putting on such matches, and his promos weren't setting the world on fire at all, so i'm not sure what exactly you're arguing about.
Out of curiosity...honestly, are people such fans of MVP, or MVP's awesome gimmick? The man played it well, but he himself was not special as wrestler.
Yep, just the lazy/ unmotivated thing. I just feel like he was did his job, and he did it well. It's tough to have a great match, when they limit the in ring time on TV and such.
As far as what i like about MVP.... I think he's a great fit for WWE. Above average mic skills, average average in the ring as a wrestler. Good character, charisma, passionate. Honestly he was the main reason why i started watching SD again in 2006, and why i still tune in now. He's entertaining. I really feel like he could have been a main event player, and i completely understand why he wasn't.
I don't think this is a huge loss for WWE....but the WWE should take notice of this trend of wrestlers wanting to leave the company, or WWE lossing talent for one reason or another. Which results in a lack of veterans to help establish the younger talent.