MTG Mafia, Angels vs. Enemies - Game Thread

[Evans]

Nah he was barely there for tiger king at all lol. He’d made 30 posts by the end of day 2 which is when he died

Yeah, when I started replying no-one had mentioned that game. Worth a look to see if he did the vote count there and looking at his entrance.

As said, I think indie or town is more likely than scum at the moment.

 

[Poyser]

I can’t get over this though:

If he was genuinely taking notes, there’d be much more there. There’s no way he just started taking notes on jeff. He passed it off as “not taking notes on a token barry wagon” - there was never a barry wagon. There was a wagon on big man, EV, OMB, magic and then jeff. There’s plenty of stuff to take notes about and I feel like town lethal has a thing or 2 to say about magic’s preaching but he didn’t even touch on it at all. I think you’re right tweet, he came into this thread with an agenda and then seemed to work backwards. It doesn’t seem indicative of someone that had just read the thread and been taking notes. Also I think I might have caught him in a lie if memory serves, let me go back and see

 

[Poyser]

To answer both of you. I had read through the thread and made little notes on my Excel doc to say that Jeff seemed scummy. I then used it as my entry thread before inserting the quotes that I'd selected to analyse and provide thoughts/comments on. The vote is in spirit because he's now on 7 votes out of 10 needed, and even though I'm feeling a scummy vibe from him, I'm not going to assist blind lynch a guy in his sleep.

Poyser, I'm essentially leaning scum on Jeff because he's sheeping you moreso than he does Odo, and doesn't seem to be generating much of all outside of his earlier attempt of case on Big Man.

Sheeping you ask? You voted Big Man, Jeff followed. You voted EV, Jeff followed. You voted OMB, Jeff followed. You voted Magic, Jeff danced around asking if it was needed, then voted.

Alright yeah lmao. His explanation for the weird order of his entrance was that he’d taken notes to know jeff was scummy and used it as his entrance, and then inserted the quotes he’d already selected to analyse and provide thoughts on

Which is a lie because when you insert the quotes it adds them all. He went back and quoted them one by one as if he was reading back the thread in real time

 

[Evans]

We still have 15 hours man, relax. He's going to swing. You're not interested in gunning for Magic?

@Poyser you mentioned Lethal's meta around Magic earlier.

He tried this with Jeff also, no mention of it on the notes.

 

[Poyser]

And here as well he’s just wildly inconsistent

Tweets started the wagon, just sayin'. I would be less tempted to put the rope around you if you could, idk, be calmer and talk it down.

Any comments on why you're appearing to be sheeping Poyser?



We still have 15 hours man, relax. He's going to swing. You're not interested in gunning for Magic?

This is in response to jeff getting angry that we’re not lynching OMB. He says OMB is getting lynched

I purposely didn't take any notes on a token Barry D1 wagon, or his soft. The OMB stuff is very warranted, and Poyser has an excellent case built up. I'd rather nail a great white today over a goldfish

But then says he wants to lynch Jeff (I don’t even think these posts are particularly far apart)

It's OMB, friend, not exactly a supreme catch. There's a remote chance he's just as forgetful as anything. I'm prone to those lapses of memory at times.



I stand corrected. You voted post #209, Poyser voted post #228. He did the leg work though. That leg work forced the claim which you've doubled down on his lying about the role.

And then here he’s acting like OMB isn’t caught? Or what? I’m not really sure I know what the point of this post even is

 

[Tweet]

Good catch Poyser, I think that's plenty of stuff for Lethal to respond to when he returns.

 

[Alco]

The thing is then, though: if Lethal's centering his thoughts and his agenda around Jeff and OMB, are they both his scum buddies? Why would he only focus on those two with the purpose of bussing?

I agree his posts around Jeff are super weird and uncomfortable, but what's the motive there?

 

[Evans]

The thing is then, though: if Lethal's centering his thoughts and his agenda around Jeff and OMB, are they both his scum buddies? Why would he only focus on those two with the purpose of bussing?

I agree his posts around Jeff are super weird and uncomfortable, but what's the motive there?

Town or SK tbh

 

[Poyser]

The thing is then, though: if Lethal's centering his thoughts and his agenda around Jeff and OMB, are they both his scum buddies? Why would he only focus on those two with the purpose of bussing?

I agree his posts around Jeff are super weird and uncomfortable, but what's the motive there?

I mean by the time he entered the thread, everyone had pretty much concluded that OMB was scum and Jeff was in big shit. You’re kinda right that it would be a bit weird to centre ALL of your thoughts around 2 of your scum buddies, but is it not even weirder that as town he centred all of his thoughts around those 2 and nobody else? It’s kinda like he had too much information lol there’s no way he didn’t think a single other person was scummy. Tho I think he eventually listed brutus as a scum lean, but as far as I can see he’s not even mentioned brutus other than that

 

[Tweet]

Yeah Lethal threw some token shade in Brutus' and Magics direction but his focus was clearly on Jeff and to a lesser extent OMB.

 

[Poyser]

If lethal is town then idk man, we are gonna have to have a chat post game about how he processes his thoughts lol and why he feels the need to lie to explain away his dodgy actions rather than just being honest

 

[Poyser]

Town (Leans):
Poyser, Barry, EV, Chris, Tweets, Banez, Rugrat, CP

Scum (Leans):
OMB, Jeff, Brutus

Null:
Lawls, Juice, Alco, PHEN0M, Big Man, Magic

Pretty comfortable with this. Will be back in a little bit to see how this thread develops.

I know you’ve got a lot to respond to but whenever you get a sec could you explain your Tweet, Banez, a Rugrat and Brutus reads here plz?

Bearing in mind this was before jeff flipped, so tweet didn’t have that going for him

 

[Tweet]

It could be that he really went through the entire thread and saw people dumping all over Jeff and OMB and decided to join in even if he himself is town tho, it doesn't seem outlandish for him to sheep those kinds of suspicions, but then there's those inconsistencies Poyser and I pointed out of Lethal basically having read everything and arriving at certain conclusions, yet still going back and forth in his thought process as soon as he puts pen to paper on posts in the actual game thread.

 

[Poyser]

I purposely didn't take any notes on a token Barry D1 wagon, or his soft. The OMB stuff is very warranted, and Poyser has an excellent case built up. I'd rather nail a great white today over a goldfish

Like he is confident OMB is scum, and he quoted some OMB posts during his “readback”, but had taken no notes on him?

 

[Poyser]

That has a lot of merit. I'm in a pickle though, as I want to vote, and my vote is on you in spirit. You've calmed a tad which is nice. Why should I vote him over you? Have you seen any connections he has? Should we be looking at teammates who are stronger targets?

I mean here he’s even offering jeff an olive branch lol