SmackDown Live Live SmackDown Discussion thread, January 3rd 2025: Nia Jax defends the WWE Womens Championship

[Cwalker]

I’m not saying put the belt on Charlotte for 8 months or whatever.

She gets it for 6 weeks

And instead of Tiffany having a cash in victory, she has this 25 minute classic where she’s crowned

 

[JakeYourBooty]

Yes let’s get a repeat of Rhea where’s it’ll take years for Tiffy to get her title back


Yeah I’m good let’s have Charlotte put her over from the jump and keep the Horsewomen all away from title reigns so the next generation can shine..with the crop that’s gonna be coming up from NXT there will be plenty of women for them to face

 

[Dale]

I’m not saying put the belt on Charlotte for 8 months or whatever.

She gets it for 6 weeks

And instead of Tiffany having a cash in victory, she has this 25 minute classic where she’s crowned

So another shit, stat padding title reign instead of just doing the deed off the bat? Really don't see the point at all lol.

 

[JakeYourBooty]

Holy shit

Dale and I are on the same page

 

[Grimoire Lenin]

Yeah not sure why it's some inflexible thing for Tiffy to just straight up beat Charlotte the first time over.

 

[Cwalker]

Y’all are crazy

 

[Grimoire Lenin]

Like if the logic is "It'll make Tiffy more popular to beat Charlotte and win the belt again", then I'd argue that Tiffy just straight up beating Charlotte the first time and successfully defending her belt would do the same job, without giving Charlotte the belt.

 

[Cwalker]

Idk but I feel like Tiff’s “crowning “moment” is Mania

 

[Grimoire Lenin]

Alright, so then explain to me how beating the most decorated woman in wrestling history clean as a whistle, while successfully defending her belt, wouldn't be a crowning moment for her?

 

[Dale]

Yes...by beating Charlotte at Mania and not losing to her

 

[Dale]

​

 

[Brandon Blaze]

Hell really froze over. Dale and Booty agreeing? Everyone get your supplies now, it’s the end of the world as we know it.

 

[Jimmy King]

I want to see Tiffy vs Charlotte but I would want Tiffy to keep the title if it ever happens.

 

[Stellar]

Charlotte vs. Tiffany at WrestleMania would be fun to watch and I have always supported Charlotte but this is one of those times that Charlotte winning wouldn't be a good idea. Especially if she will only have another short title reign. Tiffany needs to hold on to the belt for awhile.

Charlottes next title reign needs to be a lengthy one. Her last reign was basically to set up for Rhea winning the title at WrestleMania. Although over 3 months of a reign seems like a year for Charlotte compared to some of her previous reigns.

 

[Dale]

​