Let the Past Die: The Skywalker Saga - A Star Wars Mafia Game Thread

[Evans]

I’ve already told you why you’re wrong, you dismiss it as further evidence of my guilt whilst simultaneously disregarding the facts lol. There’s no discussion to be had here, you have to be willing to listen

vote EV

You have not told me why I'm wrong about scum bussing Barry, you've made it all about yourself.

 

[Evans]

Hypothetically, you're town right now. Do you honestly believe that scum bussing Barry KNOWING he's gonna get policy lynched is that outlandish?

@Odo - want to answer this?

 

[Odo]

You have not told me why I'm wrong about scum bussing Barry, you've made it all about yourself.

because there’s only me and you pushing Barry??????????

???????

???????????

 

[Comrade Khan]

What was your read list again EV

 

[TKOK]

94 pages

anyway i'll claim. I'm Rose, Hated Townie. A chance encounter with Finn took me to the front lines of the War and my sisters death made me decide to redouble my efforts in the Resistance.

 

[Odo]

I don’t think you’re mafia, I think you’re indy, which Ive said???

do you want me to discuss if I’m bussing Barry?

the fuck man

 

[Evans]

you mean the policy lynch that I myself suggested at the start of the game, in my very first post?

gee what a teammate I am

Barry has resigned himself to a policy lynch and you were the one who told us all that and Barry has already confirmed it.

Funnily enough, this was all confirmed in the argument me & Barry had where the comparison of this game v MTG went on for too long.

I don't think scum bussing Barry is at all a wild theory or an unlikely opinion, whether you're scum with him or not.

Again here @Odo, I didn't directly call you scum here. I was speaking about scum as a team bussing Barry, you instead took it as if I meant just you and ignored the rest of it.

 

[Odo]

Again here @Odo, I didn't directly call you scum here. I was speaking about scum as a team bussing Barry, you instead took it as if I meant just you and ignored the rest of it.

THERES ONLY ME AND YOU TALKING ABOUT LYNCHING BARRY

 

[Comrade Khan]

94 pages

anyway i'll claim. I'm Rose, Hated Townie. A chance encounter with Finn took me to the front lines of the War and my sisters death made me decide to redouble my efforts in the Resistance.

I love you man

 

[Evans]

I don’t think you’re mafia, I think you’re indy, which Ive said???

do you want me to discuss if I’m bussing Barry?

the fuck man

No, I'm asking you whether you are town, scum or fucking a pile of shit on the floor.

Is it outlandish that scum will bus Barry?

Jesus fuck.

 

[Odo]

No, I'm asking you whether you are town, scum or fucking a pile of shit on the floor.

Is it outlandish that scum will bus Barry?

Jesus fuck.

THERES ONLY ME AND YOU TALKING ABOUT LYNCHING BARRY

 

[Evans]

THERES ONLY ME AND YOU TALKING ABOUT LYNCHING BARRY

SO WHEN I FLIP TOWN AND EVERYONE LOOKS AT BARRY LIKE THEY'VE SAID THEY WILL

BARRY IS THE LIKELIEST NEXT LYNCH

 

[Comrade Khan]

Barry will be figured out one way or another in short order I imagine

 

[Smart Marx]

unvote
vote odo

I'm back and honestly most of this stuff feels like running in circles, but:

Odo is not necessarily arguing poorly, but my experience is that he'd be a bit more aggressive and... rude?... although I'm nervous to go all in on this read given era. I wouldn't be against lynching him but I'm not completely sold on him being scum - although the lean is in that direction.

Poyser feels fine. Not much more to say.

I'm actually going to retract my earlier read on CP - while I definitely have experienced him being laid back and trolly as town, and the inverse as maf, there is clearly something different in this game vs last game in how he is posting. If others can confirm that CP actually has a history of playing properly and getting involved as town, I'm actually willing to give him a town lean.

Jeff - null. He's active and getting involved but nothing has really stood out to me either way.

EV - Also willing to pull out of my earlier read a bit as I think his return has been fine (and not because he was nice to me ) - it feels like a town move.
Regardless of what is meta here I'm inclined to not vote out a tracker d1 - the possibility of a maf tracker is noted but that doesn't mean I'm willing to play that roulette game. Still keeping an eye on EV though.

Tweet - Meh. Still think posting has been okay I guess. also just ftr the whole Tweet OP sarcasm shit is a non-argument as it was slightly ambiguous when I read it but clearly not a slip of any kind so meeeeeeh.

Unvote

As it stands I honestly don't know who I'd want to lynch. I'd be okay with Odo, Barry maybe but tbph I'm not convinced on anyone. Not very helpful I know and I'm sure I'll be accused of fencesitting for this read list but hey ho.

I would like to see guys like Big Man and Alco, who have recently reared their heads, giving more feedback.

I am somewhat inclined to get a claim out of Odo at the very least, with the only thing somewhat holding this back being that we've got a couple guys outed and if Odo is town its handing even more info out to scum. But fuck it, I don't really see a better avenue.

Vote Odo

I'm gonna vote now since I may not be on when the 48 hour window is over. I was favorin' Jeff over Tweet durin' the early part. So I'll go Jeff for now. If I get on and see more information, I'll change my vote then.

vote: Jeff

Tell you what, I’ll get the ball rolling, see where the chips land

Vote Barry

vote e-v

excellent

Bingo.

Vote EV

Unvote
Vote EV

In case I have to unvote before voting.

Vote EV

hes gonna be an anti Han Solo indy

PS good job Han Solo hasn’t claimed if this is right!

Oh. Okay. Vote: EV

Actually, there is precedent for this

unvote

Offcial Vote: EV

live is long and prosper

vote EV

Vote: E-V

I just can't buy the Fett man as town

:

vote Evans

Ya seems like it's this or nothing. FWIW I don't think Jeff and Ace are making this orange town stuff all up cause if Evans is town this'd be a damn shortsighted play.

unvote

I’ve already told you why you’re wrong, you dismiss it as further evidence of my guilt whilst simultaneously disregarding the facts lol. There’s no discussion to be had here, you have to be willing to listen

vote EV

A Demo God Production of Skywalker Saga Mafia
The surviving members of the resistance face the First Order once again,
and the legendary conflict between the Jedi and the Sith reaches its peak bringing the Skywalker saga to its end.

Midday 1 Vote Count

E-V (8) - Jeff Valley Driver, Ace Dalton, Grim Cornette, OMB, Alco, Lethal Banks, Odo
Odo (2) - CraigPelton, Poyser
Jeff Valley Driver (2) - PHEN0M, Shania Twain
Grim Cornette (1) - E-V

With 18 players remaining in the game, it takes 10 votes to reach a lynch.

Day 1 will end on Monday, Aug 31st, at 7:00 PM ET.​

 

[CraigPelton]

TKOK having no time for Odo's cautions about claiming character lmao, what a legend