Let the Past Die: The Skywalker Saga - A Star Wars Mafia Game Thread

[Comrade Khan]

I'm stickin' to the OP about character claiming tbh.

This is the way.

you MAY character claim. while the OP warns against recruitment, I don't see anywhere that says you shouldn't character claim outside the reasons Odo stated. So please don't hide behind the OP. If you are going to claim your freakin secondary alignment (galactic empire), you are already hinting (for wtv reason?)

 

[Odo]

 

[Evans]

you MAY character claim. while the OP warns against recruitment, I don't see anywhere that says you shouldn't character claim outside the reasons Odo stated. So please don't hide behind the OP. If you are going to claim your freakin secondary alignment (galactic empire), you are already hinting (for wtv reason?)

I'm not hiding behind the OP, I'm telling you directly lol.

 

[Lethal]

EV's big receipts post if anything has made me more suss of him as it feels like a desperation scum play trying to look town by pulling out receipts.

I think there are few things that work as well at changing town's mind than someone putting a ton of effort into digging up individual posts to make an argument in that way but here it feels forced and intentional.

Vote EV

EV's flip gives a lot of information anyway I feel. If he is scum, I think at least one of Tweet and Jeff is probably scum too (See my earlier argument that scum EV doesn't jump into a town v town argument between Jeff and Tweet). And Barry becomes a fair bit more clear.

I'm not sure we have a better direction at this point.

But 3 hours later you vote for EV and say that it could provide a link between EV and Tweet as scum. How does EV being scum refute your initial read (and receipts) of Tweet? What changed in those 3 hours to make you doubt your town read of Tweet?

 

[Tweet]

lol no I didn't. Tweet made a stink about it, I asked a question. Don't make shit up

You know I love to warm up this stew again. You didn't read the OP yea? So how did you know there was no night posting allowed in this game?

 

[Comrade Khan]

Are you saying you are Orange Town AND Galactic Empire EV?

 

[Comrade Khan]

Please let EV answer this btw, it's relevant.

 

[Alco]

Well, in the name of Id probably keep the suggestions to yourself until you know whats actually happened

In today's world, shouting opinions when only knowing half of the story is pretty commonplace. Just trying to fit in.

 

[Evans]

Are you saying you are Orange Town AND Galactic Empire EV?

Republic/Empire and orange town, my specific role is 'Town Tracker' just to be sure

 

[Chris]

I'm finally mostly caught up (except for maybe the last couple pages or so) after being busier this weekend than I planned.

Still leaning Jeff as town, liked Alco a lot when he started playing too.

Really don't know who would be the best lynch here, Grim has probably looked the worst for me but he's perpetual D1 mislynch material and I've thought he was scum plenty of times for doing erratic shit. Probably still our best bet since I kind of don't want to touch Odo/Poyser yet. Both are making good points and not so good ones too I'm getting t/t vibes from another game (can't remember which) where Magic and Odo argued forever on end but were both town. If Odo is town then I'd def think one of Poyser/CP/Tweet were scum. If he's scum then they could all just be right bc idk if Odo would let a teammate jump on him so early?

Also one thing bugging me about Grim's claim is it's hider/commuter, are multiple roles like that common for Smark?

 

[Ace]

I could swear Ive seen you give him a bigger endoresement than that? Ill check later

Don't think so. I was critical of EV's posts in his argument with Barry and said that EV flipping scum would make Barry clearer. That may be what you're thinking of.

 

[Chris]

Just to make sure I have all the claims

EV - Tracker
Grim - Hider/commuter
Odo - Gunsmith or something of the like?

 

[Comrade Khan]

Republic/Empire and orange town, my specific role is 'Town Tracker' just to be sure

I'd like someone to confirm this. I don't think this is true...

 

[Evans]

Just to make sure I have all the claims

EV - Tracker
Grim - Hider/commuter
Odo - Gunsmith or something of the like?

Lethal - DV

 

[Comrade Khan]

Just to make sure I have all the claims

EV - Tracker
Grim - Hider/commuter
Odo - Gunsmith or something of the like?

he said detective ( a gunsmith variant)