Let the Past Die: The Skywalker Saga - A Star Wars Mafia Game Thread

[Evans]

Which part do you not think is true? I can confirm half of it.

Which bit can you confirm?

 

[Tweet]

Voting you today would be completely futile, if you’re scum

This is completely different from stuff town Odo has said in the past, I remember in some game you started a new wagon on CP saying you believe he and another player are scum and you want to cut off the snake's head first.

 

[Chris]

I count 4 different "town" colors in the OP

 

[Odo]

I think Odo wanted this to happen

Huh? Im defending you mate, Poyser wants (wanted, I dunno) to lynch you as recently as a few hours ago

 

[Poyser]

I mean, it's pretty much true that Odo voting Poyser wouldn't achieve anything other than make him look even weaker imo. It's not going to track any votes as he's under pressure, and no one is really reading poyser scum.

But what’s his alternate direction? I’d understand if he had a direction he would strongly prefer but he doesn’t lol he’s voting barry after earlier saying himself voting barry would be useless as we won’t lynch him today

 

[Odo]

Ok, its the pals era, but im fucking losing patience here

IT IS NOT THE SAME VOTING A STRONG PLAYER IN A NEUTRAL GAME STATE AS IT IS TRYING TO PRESSURE THEM WHEN THEY ARE LEADING A WAGON AGAINST YOU WITH ACTUAL SUPPORT

 

[Lethal]

It doesn't. My logic was that EV as scum doesn't insert himself into a town-town battle and draw attention to himself as he did.

Therefore, if he flipped scum, it would imply that someone between Jeff and Tweet was scum.

I would lean towards Jeff being scum over Tweet based on my town read of Tweet.

Appreciate the reply and effort. Your replies to my queries have been more than fine.

I think I wanna derpclear Lethal as town for not knowing there's multiple town alignments. The OP makes it kinda clear but also IIRC Smark always sends his list of full fakes to the entire mafia team and I'm thinking the chance of all their fakes being of the same town alignment/colour is fairly low, so if he'd seen the list of fakes it's very likely he would have known there were multiple town alignments.

Can't help but feel a little insulted here

 

[Tweet]

I do agree though that lynching anyone really is gonna be tough cause at this stage it'd take pretty much everybody who's actually playing to agree on something.

 

[Canadian Dragon]

I count 4 different "town" colors in the OP

i only see green, orange, blue?

 

[Odo]

But what’s his alternate direction? I’d understand if he had a direction he would strongly prefer but he doesn’t lol he’s voting barry after earlier saying himself voting barry would be useless as we won’t lynch him today

Im also happy to vote and lynch literally any of the inactives

 

[Poyser]

I'm finally mostly caught up (except for maybe the last couple pages or so) after being busier this weekend than I planned.

Still leaning Jeff as town, liked Alco a lot when he started playing too.

Really don't know who would be the best lynch here, Grim has probably looked the worst for me but he's perpetual D1 mislynch material and I've thought he was scum plenty of times for doing erratic shit. Probably still our best bet since I kind of don't want to touch Odo/Poyser yet. Both are making good points and not so good ones too I'm getting t/t vibes from another game (can't remember which) where Magic and Odo argued forever on end but were both town. If Odo is town then I'd def think one of Poyser/CP/Tweet were scum. If he's scum then they could all just be right bc idk if Odo would let a teammate jump on him so early?

Also one thing bugging me about Grim's claim is it's hider/commuter, are multiple roles like that common for Smark?

Tbf the bottom brings up a good point

Why would barry claim the commuter part to his role, as scum? I know it’s barry but it makes no sense and presumably he would have talked about it in a qt considering it’s not like he was being hammered when he claimed

 

[Lethal]

Game has been going strong and no sighting of TKOK, to date.

:

 

[Tweet]

Can't help but feel a little insulted here

Don't be, all I'm saying is that I think you don't know about something that the scum team almost certainly know about and I don't think you'd fake that so you're likely town.

 

[Lethal]

Don't be, all I'm saying is that I think you don't know about something that the scum team almost certainly know about and I don't think you'd fake that so you're likely town.

 

[Ace]

I have a hard time believing the colour orange represents what he says it does, let's put it that way

Which bit can you confirm?

There's no beating about the bush here. I'm orange and town.