Knights of the Old Republic Mafia - Game Thread

[Poyser]

I don't even think this is accurate, but also my claim probably isn't gonna cause anybody to unvote.

Why waste time then? If it’s so inconsequential then why not offer it up. What are you hoping to get out of getting more votes first? Surely that just makes it more likely you’ll be lynched if it’s not gonna sway anybody?

 

[Tweet]

so tweet from your POV you thought Jeff was trying to get a wagon on himself and would then claim and find the scum off the wagon. you also thought Poyser was aware of this. can you explain why this would make Poyser more likely scum. would this not put him under risk, if Jeff is trying to get votes on himself and Poyser is aware of it why does Poyser need to help move the wagon along? it should happen by itself no?

I don't think I've said it makes him more likely to be scum, I made points for why he could play it the way he did as either alignment and overall found it a pretty null move. At any rate I'd trust him to find the right reasoning to make it look like something town motivated, he's a good player and there's a good chance anything he tries to sell is gonna work.

 

[Poyser]

I mean you implied it makes me more likely to be scum when you voted for me

 

[Tweet]

Cowardly Scum, inactive scum, mild to highly active town.

That said I haven’t played in along time so me being as active as I am could be anything.

Best people to ask Poyser, Jam or CP I guess, I hope this helps.

FWIW you actually posting in this game unlike that one other game I mentioned is something I noticed, but without actual meta to go off of it's not enough to actually translate it into a read.

 

[Poyser]

Tweet can’t explain his prior logic which is why he keeps trying to apply the “now I realise there is town motivations for it” to his past opinion which obviously doesn’t work lol

 

[Tweet]

I mean you implied it makes me more likely to be scum when you voted for me

Yes I did and I explained that back then I had no idea that this world where Jeff had a role that gets powered up by people voting him existed, so I saw no town motivation in you voting him despite knowing that he probably has a good role. We've talked about this, I misunderstood something.

 

[NotBrutus]

Doddsy a lot more active than he usually is, maybe he’s having a bit too much fun with his PR

I'm gonna go out on a limb and give Smark a small town read for being overly cautious.

 

[Tweet]

Tweet can’t explain his prior logic which is why he keeps trying to apply the “now I realise there is town motivations for it” to his past opinion which obviously doesn’t work lol

Why does it not work?

 

[Poyser]

But I mean big man was clearly asking you how you thought this BACK THEN.

 

[Tweet]

Oh another reason why my claim is gonna suck is that it has a modifier on it that I love to shoehorn in there as scum so it's gonna look like a classic Tweet fake.

 

[Poyser]

Why does it not work?

Because you can’t explain PAST logic with information you’ve found out since then lol

 

[Poyser]

Oh another reason why my claim is gonna suck is that it has a modifier on it that I love to shoehorn in there as scum so it's gonna look like a classic Tweet fake.

 

[Poyser]

Might as well come out with it now

 

[Big Man]

but the misunderstanding doesn’t matter. the point is you’re not able to explain why you voted him when based on your understanding at the time of your vote what Poyser was doing was null at best like you said.

vote tweet

 

[Tweet]

But I mean big man was clearly asking you how you thought this BACK THEN.

Yes and I explained why it's a null thing and I also explained why I wanted to wagon you, because I had no earthly idea why you would push that wagon despite having to know that Jeff is up to something and I wanted to see what was going on.