Fact is ROH isn't shit, they still have no major deal and mean fuck all. Make no excuses about their market etc, they are a simple pimple on the ass in terms of importance, they aren't the equivalent of ecw in the 90s or AWA in the 80s, and they haven't amounted to shot no matter how much smoke Cornette or some Indy midgets want to blow up your ass.
Fact is TNA has nowhere to tape, lost their founder, can't sign back their stars, and are going to have a hell of a time if they lose the one thing keeping them floating and that's their spike deal. You don't think they would pull it? I got news for you, they are part of the network that dropped ecw for raw and would drop impact so fast for SmackDown your head would spin. That happens and its death, it was death for WCW when they wouldn't have a home for nitro or thunder and it was death for ecw, both of whom were more valuable than TNA has ever been
What does JJ and Keith have that TNA doesn't if they wanted to start? JJ started TNA like it or not. JJ has spent the past couple years making contacts in Mexico, India, and he brokered deals with Japan and the NWA before. He brokered their ppv deal to start with alongside his father. It started the background for TNA. TNA got to tour at the beginning because it was jarrett who arranged a deal with hermit Sadler to cover the costs of live events. Keith has more experience than Dixie, there's a difference between Dixie and Keith. Keith earned his money, he made his money, he worked for his money, while Dixie's daddy handed TNA to her as a gift. A gift that's ran on a negative, she's not Stephanie, she didn't spend years learning the business in every facet and doing work to help build her own status and money, she was just an heir with a gift that is slowly dying. JJ the performer has name value and he can start, Sting can work and be used, and AJ can be used to appeal to a southern wrasslin fan and audience on a cmt. They can use the NWA to get appearances and give them some credibility and some talent appearances, they can appeal to names who aren't signed but have some face recognition like MVP, Benjamin, Carlito, Master, Brian Lawler (the fuck you thinking talking about King), and the like the same way NWA TNA was started by using Killing, James, Waltman, Hall, Hennig, Lynn, DLo, Konnan, Raven, and Jarrett. You would have to be ignorant to ignore the world cups, talent sharing, and everything associated with njpw and aaa guys working TNA events for years especially when they had NWA attached to their names weren't Jarrett brokered and be used over here for this promotion. You're kidding yourself if you don't think he can compete with TNA who is using Magnus, Anderson, Bubba, Kaz, EC3 and Daniels as their top guys and can't even run ppvs, move tickets, or book a venue to film from.