"I Wanna Play A Game" - Saw Mafia - Game Thread

[RDK]

unvote

 

[Showtime]

unvote

why you unvote breh?

 

[RDK]

Fine with a no lynch, we are already down one town and have a 95% confirmed Odo. I'm not satisfied that Big Man is scum enough to hang my hat on it, some of the votes on him have been poor at best and a big benefit of the flip being a read on Odo isn't really relevant as he is already confirmed.

Off to bed

 

[Showtime]

ya we're not no lynching. the whole point of getting everyone's thoughts and opinions wasn't to end with nothing because then i just got a whole lot of nothing from it.

 

[Showtime]

and before someone hits me with the "you always say it's fine to no lynch day 1"

ya when nothing is happening and going in a direction would be cause most people are forcing it, but both options have had people weigh in and will actually give shit off the wagon.

 

[Kim Jong Umb]

I personally dont like the no lynch idea in any game given how at least town has a chance of hitting mafia with it compared to just giving them a free shot at a nk. Thats just my personal belief

 

[RDK]

I think either is fine tbh And I fully expect you to get the big man wagon done without me so go full steam ahead. I'll be interested to see who contributes

 

[Rugrat]

Which players don't you like from the wagon, Haza?

 

[RDK]

Which players don't you like from the wagon, Haza?

The 5 and 6 spots on the wagon which in my mind tend to be scummy spots have one of my slight scum leans in Evans and mikey who has been pretty uninspired too. I should start looking into some possible connections tomorrow. Maybe

 

[Showtime]

If you're not voting, you should vote. There's no reason for most of you not to be.

@Doddsy vote one of the two wagons


I'm still leaning towards cp myself.

 

[Rugrat]

If you're not voting, you should vote. There's no reason for most of you not to be.

@Doddsy vote one of the two wagons


I'm still leaning towards cp myself.

what was the point in the very recent posts pertaining to set-up suggesting Big Man was scummier

 

[Showtime]

what was the point in the very recent posts pertaining to set-up suggesting Big Man was scummier

To showcase info. Should I have kept it secret? I looked at his old setups to see how he used tracker

 

[Rugrat]

To showcase info. Should I have kept it secret? I looked at his old setups to see how he used tracker

Yes

There's a case for and against every lynch, particularly at a formative part of a game. I don't see the need to bring up info to discredit your own case, when it just reduces the likelihood of getting your way. When presenting your lynch you should be putting forward the case as strongly as possible - which doesn't include digging up a counter-argument you can't defend against. This is especially true when there's a very stubborn player adamant for the competing wagon.

 

[Showtime]

Yes

There's a case for and against every lynch, particularly at a formative part of a game. I don't see the need to bring up info to discredit your own case, when it just reduces the likelihood of getting your way. When presenting your lynch you should be putting forward the case as strongly as possible - which doesn't include digging up a counter-argument you can't defend against. This is especially true when there's a very stubborn player adamant for the competing wagon.

Disagree. If I want to simply get my lynch sure, but I present info for everyone to analyse.

 

[Odo]

I personally dont like the no lynch idea in any game given how at least town has a chance of hitting mafia with it compared to just giving them a free shot at a nk. Thats just my personal belief

I’m right with you lad