"I Wanna Play A Game" - Saw Mafia - Game Thread

[Doddsy]

a little bit yeah. Those cop variants are crippling in small games where 1 mislynch makes all the difference (and it’d actually be two mislynches cause magic was a gunsmith and it’s too easy to sell lethal as having faked - that’s not game design that flies in 2020)

I'll explain my reasoning a bit more. If Lethal is scum, he had to have either, created the gambit himself and gone with it, without feedback, or been given the play and also been told to claim a cop immediately after a gunsmith flip. I just can't line that up in my head as being a smart move for scum to make

 

[Odo]

Why would he care enough for Lethal to use his role on Poyser for a guilty when the tracker flipped? Surely he doesn’t have to worry about someone catching his target?

still a decent chance poyser was watched

 

[Odo]

I'll explain my reasoning a bit more. If Lethal is scum, he had to have either, created the gambit himself and gone with it, without feedback, or been given the play and also been told to claim a cop immediately after a gunsmith flip. I just can't line that up in my head as being a smart move for scum to make

nah, I think he’s the rolecop, and scum (cp) deduced claiming cop was in play

 

[Junkette]

True.

They obviously didn’t factor in Magic flipping gunsmith and probably had the plan ready before his flip, Lethal went ahead without thinking

 

[Odo]

I'll explain my reasoning a bit more. If Lethal is scum, he had to have either, created the gambit himself and gone with it, without feedback, or been given the play and also been told to claim a cop immediately after a gunsmith flip. I just can't line that up in my head as being a smart move for scum to make

but I’ll humour you. Let’s say lethals pm days town cop - why is it more likely he’s some shitty variant than his target was driven?

 

[Doddsy]

How quick was his first post after night

 

[Junkette]

Very quick, almost anticipated

 

[Odo]

Pretty quick

he also came out with a ‘vote to lynch’ on CP, and then said that his results were fucked with

how do those 2 things compute

 

[Doddsy]

but I’ll humour you. Let’s say lethals pm days town cop - why is it more likely he’s some shitty variant than his target was driven?

It was an alternative I thought of earlier and lethal posted the pic of his character which reinforced that idea to me. I mean I may be wrong in that situation but either of those scenarios would result in him being town, as opposed to the gambit one being harder to buy for me.

I could believe it was pre-planned and Lethal jumped the gun as Junk's saying he came in real quick

 

[Junkette]

I have mostly the same list as you Odo btw.

Haza, Rugrat, Lethal, Brutus, maybe Poyser v2.

 

[Junkette]

Rugrat’s claim makes his slot weird though

 

[Poyser]

Pretty quick

he also came out with a ‘vote to lynch’ on CP, and then said that his results were fucked with

how do those 2 things compute

Ye this is what I said lol, it was obviously premeditated as he didn’t wait to get opinions and clarification on his “messed up results” at all. His actions said yeah he was bus driven whilst his words were saying huh I’m confused lmao

 

[Odo]

3 minutes between EOD and lethals post

and there’s a lot of ‘thoughts’ in lethals post

yeah I’m thinking pre meditated

 

[Junkette]

Not a huge fan of Doddsy repping insanity spec over just Poyser v1 being driven if he thinks Lethal is town.

 

[Doddsy]

@Odo I'm going to claim and share my stuff with someone competent. Shenanigans were afoot last night, and I have proof.

Let's just start off with

Vote: CP

and this is a vote to lynch

I mean that reads to me that he thinks he was bus driven tbh.