Both Andy's and I's "opinions" are filled with logic. His suggestion of a criteria makes it fair for everybody. To say you just liked an RP better than an another, that's a weak system to have. Where as if you're actually reading it, and seeing that it follows some form of criteria, it makes your system much stronger. There is clearly no logic coming from you, when you constantly say it's not going to work, without a logical explanation as to why it won't work. Instead, all I'm getting from what you post is "I don't like new ideas, they scurr me." Fact of the matter is Andy's suggestion of criteria DID work for our successfully run PWA, for 3 YEARS! Now, before I go on, please tell me, or copy and paste all of the posts I have made where I mentioned PWA. PLEASE! I have hardly said anything about PWA, except for a small reference in an RP. PWA is in the past, but, from what I'm seeing, Andy(a very experienced e-fedder) is trying to help you out, with a very simple suggestion. This same suggestion worked for XWE, an e-fed I was in, and that fed ran for 12+ years!
Now, I like the product that is being brought out in ACW here, but the staff needs to be much more open to suggestions.