Grading System

[John McHenry]

The grading system is very loose but the following is the best way to describe it.

The main criteria is Creativity, Continuity and Readability.

The four members of staff vote on who they thought won the match. In the event of a tie it'll be a draw or a DQ. No one person is deciding winners.

Keep in mind that sometimes a loss isn't because your RP was worse but because due to storyline it was necessary. Say we wanted to move a guy to a higher division he would have to lose a title most likely even. Just a loose example.

 

[Rated R Superstar]

Why lose a title?

 

[John McHenry]

Because were not going to have the same guy winning and unifying two titles when it's not necessary.

 

[Rated R Superstar]

So basically you take away shit if he's successful?

I don't see why they shouldn't have to defend both titles if they have them both. And no, I'm not trying to start an argument here at all, but it just seems like someone is being punished for winning.

 

[Slim]

then looks like the rules def need to be re-written cause I made sure to write in the rules that somethin like that would be fine cause the person earned it.

 

[Andy]

Personally, I think Primetime's comment about the titles was pretty vague. I doubt they would actually strip anyone of a title. And a unification between a high-tier title and a middle-tier title would never happen. It's nice to see this finally posted though, after waiting for so freakin' long. I don't give a fuck about how vague it is at this point. It can obviously be refined. I'm just glad it's here.

 

[BDC]

Probably the comment about unification or losing to be promoted should have been left to the staff. I know I've been out of the loop lately & I'm sorry. But just take the beginning comments as the main criteria, cause it is

 

[John McHenry]

I think everyone is misinterpreting the comment about titles. If someone is to move up to a higher title they have to lose the title they have. What happens if Snow is never defeated for the International Title? He's supposed to keep it and get the Heavyweight title too?

BDC we had all talked about that at some point. But yes the meat of the thread is the "grading" sorry that it's vague but it's better than nothing. If I wrote a list of things you had to meet in order to win that wouldn't be very fun would it?


I'll be closing this thread and deleting comments in a few days just for the sake of cleanliness.

 

[Rated R Superstar]

I don't see the problem in that, if he's earned it and all. Or are we not supposed to be successful?

 

[Slim]

I just propose someone start a thread to discuss championships. That way none of the other threads will be flooded with talks with it and it will all be centered in one. Because some roster seems to be on board and others don't.

 

[Andy]

I agree with Slim, and on top of that, the subject could be polled. lol.

 

[Slim]

And you know when we agree... it has to be a good idea

but back to the topic at hand... grading system looks pretty good... good basic outline. Be good to flesh it out a little bit sometime down the road.