"Glory, Hallelujah" | Barry Presents - The American Civil War - Mafia GAME THREAD

[Comrade Khan]

I mean regardless if I thought he was doomed or not @Poyser , I saw him change his claim to VT, said WAIT in the thread to go check my results, and then said it. I'm not sure why I wouldn't share that with the class, unless you feel I gave away my role too much? Ultimately thought I had confirmation he was lying and got excited a.f

 

[CraigPelton]

@CraigPelton @RDK @Doddsy you guys are decent at night action analysis

is there any way jeff isn’t scum here?

like to analyse what’s apparently happened

Jeff loses his role if he targets a VT. He claims to have targeted lethal N1 and didn’t lose his role

The only way this could be true and both be town would be if Lethal was bus driven and Jeff actually targeted somebody else right? I can’t think of anything else? Let me know if you can

thing is, if scum are bus driving lethal then what’s the point? They didn’t kill him so why would they bus drive? It doesn’t make any sense

also them even having a bus drive at all means they have a roleblock (again, this is assuming Jeff is town and telling the truth as he said he knows he was blocked last night), that jammer role AND a bus driver. Does that seem likely?

the only thing is I can’t really see why jeff would do it when lethal was fucked lol? That doesn’t make sense either. But then I’d say that for town jeff as well and I commented on it at the time, there was no need to out that info at all because lethal was doomed.

We are on the exact same page except for the concluding jeff is scum part, because of the last paragraph

 

[Poyser]

Jeff maybe Barry didn't tell you that you lost you role but you did?

Can’t be cos he claims he knows he was blocked last night

 

[Comrade Khan]

When did lethal say he was cop? They might have bus driven him with their kill target?

d1 when I threatened him with the Despy shot

 

[RDK]

Can’t be cos he claims he knows he was blocked last night

Yeah because phenom died...but phenom probably died bc he is a VT now not a bodyguard

 

[Ace Marvel]

When did lethal say he was cop? They might have bus driven him with their kill target?

D1 to avoid the desperado shot.

 

[Comrade Khan]

Can’t be cos he claims he knows he was blocked last night

I mean I can ask Barry if he made a mistake but I feel like he would have PMd me by now

 

[CraigPelton]

Hmm okay well that does make it less likely they would bus drive him, making it more likely you are scum. Thanks for the clarification.......

 

[Poyser]

I mean regardless if I thought he was doomed or not @Poyser , I saw him change his claim to VT, said WAIT in the thread to go check my results, and then said it. I'm not sure why I wouldn't share that with the class, unless you feel I gave away my role too much? Ultimately thought I had confirmation he was lying and got excited a.f

Yeah basically, I thought it was obvious lethal was fucked and you didn’t really need to out that facet of your role

 

[Comrade Khan]

Yeah because phenom died...but phenom probably died bc he is a VT now not a bodyguard

he had 3 shots according to the flip tho

 

[Poyser]

We are on the exact same page except for the concluding jeff is scum part, because of the last paragraph

Ah ok so what do you think the goal was with bus driving lethal?

 

[Poyser]

Yeah because phenom died...but phenom probably died bc he is a VT now not a bodyguard

No he says it’s a variation on his role

 

[RDK]

he had 3 shots according to the flip tho

No I'm saying if you are town. What's probably happened is you've lost your role night 1, barry didn't tell you (by design or not) so you weren't blocked last night, you've just been a VT since night 1 unknowingly

 

[CraigPelton]

Ah ok so what do you think the goal was with bus driving lethal?

In light of the fact lethal had softed cop before n1, I have no clue

 

[Ace Marvel]

@CraigPelton @RDK @Doddsy you guys are decent at night action analysis

is there any way jeff isn’t scum here?

like to analyse what’s apparently happened

Jeff loses his role if he targets a VT. He claims to have targeted lethal N1 and didn’t lose his role

The only way this could be true and both be town would be if Lethal was bus driven and Jeff actually targeted somebody else right? I can’t think of anything else? Let me know if you can

thing is, if scum are bus driving lethal then what’s the point? They didn’t kill him so why would they bus drive? It doesn’t make any sense

also them even having a bus drive at all means they have a roleblock (again, this is assuming Jeff is town and telling the truth as he said he knows he was blocked last night), that jammer role AND a bus driver. Does that seem likely?

the only thing is I can’t really see why jeff would do it when lethal was fucked lol? That doesn’t make sense either. But then I’d say that for town jeff as well and I commented on it at the time, there was no need to out that info at all because lethal was doomed.

I mentioned earlier that now that we don't have a claim cop, and might not even be one. Mafia doesn't need to alter results, with the jammer i doubt they have something like that.

Mando claimed
He and tweet visited Lethal + 2
one of those is RD

I'll go back and look if Mando ever softed that RD was there.

Because if he was, then he was not bus drove anywhere since he was on his target.