"Glory, Hallelujah" | Barry Presents - The American Civil War - Mafia GAME THREAD

[Comrade Khan]

Tommy has kept claiming he's busy most of the game. This is a jumps to conclusions but that slip just seems too easy for me. If I'm scum and know I can no longer commit to the game. I address it in chat. A false slip would do wonders. Town get excited about it as it's the first scum kill and will by any falsehoods you might also let slip in.

I think Tommys slip was planned.

huh, I mean that's interesting. It would be original but I cant say Ive ever seen this happen

 

[John McHenry]

I mean theres 9 scum leans there and its not even including tommy lol. Im not really sure what to make of it

Doesn't need to include Tommy he's outted. And yeah some of them are wrong just based on numbers.

 

[T-Pein™]

My list

Sister Abigail - Ekko has played quite a few games, I was wrong on my initial sus of Ekko and he started to convert me then died... He's been back and forth on SA but lean more as SA town so while not completely clear, I'm not longer completely sold on him as scum. Ekkos flip is really what changed this for me.

Ace Marvel - I'm still for him as scum this is because I don't think he and SA are on the same team. If they are, they're playing it great. I also don't have the benefit of knowing how good people are. AM has been combative in a lot of post (especially with SA, Ekko, and myseltf) or just trying to boost post numbers.

Poyser - The more the game goes on the less town vibes I'm getting. The last time I expressed my doubts his reaction was a bit much. I also didn't think he and Ekko were on the same team with Ekko flipping... I'm leaning scum on him.

Red Dragon - I feel like he's not playing any differently than his first life. That could be a solid move for scum but still believe he's town.

Phenom - I'd put leans scum

Showtime - Leans Scum

WPE - Leans scum

Such a low post count on the three above I just gotta think that they're not confident and afraid of being sus out.

Oneiros - I can't express why but I feel he's scum.

Lethal Banks - I'm not sure I've expressed a read on him before and that's because I've gone back and forth so much with him.

RDK - Shares a lot of info, I'm not recalling too many opinions or reads. It's a helluva long thread and he came in late, so I'm taking a wait and see more approach. So for now I'll leans town.

Craig Pelton - Leans scum

Baldrick - The whole I won't do a duel if you guys tell me too Oh but I'll duel tweet. Seems like a town should agree to go for a duel the town wants, scum is only going to duel someone they know isn't scum. I go scum.

T-Pein - His read list #3,048 seems to agree with a lot of mine at the time. But since then he hasn't really shared his opinion. He also voted for Ace alongside me so I'll keep him green for now.

Doddsy - Also tends to agree with me but he's given few reads. Also voted to lynch Marvel. But has disagreed with RDK quite a bit. I'll put as town for now.


@Red Dragon @RDK @Ace Marvel thoughts?

You need more towns.
Scums on point tho.

 

[Poyser]

You need more towns.
Scums on point tho.

kek which ones do you agree with

 

[RDK]

You really should just be white probably.

Ace's posts get so random at times it feels like he's trolling or just being rando aggressive out of boredom.

I have always felt like one of them was attempting to lead the pack and one was always pretending it went back and forth with Ekko flipping town Poyser dropped down for me. I could certainly be wrong.

If it helps Poyser mentioned he did this in champs and was just burned out town

 

[Poyser]

Doesn't need to include Tommy he's outted. And yeah some of them are wrong just based on numbers.

Yeah im aware, just means if you add tommy into the mix thats 10. more than half the game left alive

 

[Doddsy]

It's pretty obviously a defense when the guy is under massive pressure and you're giving reasons you don't think he's scum , cmon let's not play semantics

You completely ignored the reasons he was being lynched in your reasoning too. Your explanation was fine if there wasn't all the other stuff to go with it. Just looks like good guy guying on reflection and knowing holt flipped town

That's bullshit though and you're fully aware of it.

I read Holt town before there was any pressure on him, and the reasoning given was unconvincing. Giving reasons as to why I think he's town and there's better vote options does not equal defending.

You also seemed ready to paint it in a bad light regardless of flip, which doesn't really add up with the reasons you've given here.

Tommy has kept claiming he's busy most of the game. This is a jumps to conclusions but that slip just seems too easy for me. If I'm scum and know I can no longer commit to the game. I address it in chat. A false slip would do wonders. Town get excited about it as it's the first scum kill and will by any falsehoods you might also let slip in.

I think Tommys slip was planned.

I don't think so. Take a rep if needed you don't fak ea slip and just let a member die

 

[John McHenry]

If it helps Poyser mentioned he did this in champs and was just burned out town

I did see that but Ekko defending SA had me flip SA and I don't think SA and Ace are on the same team.

 

[Poyser]

I did see that but Ekko defending SA had me flip SA and I don't think SA and Ace are on the same team.

When people say "i dont think x and y are on the same team" it usually means they're not on the same scum team

town butt heads with each other all the time though. why couldnt they be on the same town team?

 

[John McHenry]

When people say "i dont think x and y are on the same team" it usually means they're not on the same scum team

town butt heads with each other all the time though. why couldnt they be on the same town team?

That's a fair point. Could just be going hard at each other both not knowing the other is town but while SA seems to try to take time to talk things out Ace doesn't , at least not with SA so far.

Maybe @Sister Abigail and @Ace Marvel could give reads on each other and try to talk it out.

 

[RDK]

That's bullshit though and you're fully aware of it.

I read Holt town before there was any pressure on him, and the reasoning given was unconvincing. Giving reasons as to why I think he's town and there's better vote options does not equal defending.

You also seemed ready to paint it in a bad light regardless of flip, which doesn't really add up with the reasons you've given here.

I don't think so. Take a rep if needed you don't fak ea slip and just let a member die

When the case was presented your reasons for not voting for him and going Ace Marvel instead were that you've forced reads as town before too but this completed ignored the fact he had invented flips on people that hadn't posted or he didn't know who they were, something i'm sure you've never done. You didn't address this as I think you would have if you were town trying to read him accurately, you ignored it

 

[T-Pein™]

My town core.

McNightstalker
Sister Abigail
Poyser
Lethal

Towns.

Phenom
Showtime.
Baldrick.

Scum leans

Red dragon
Wang

Scums

Oneiros
Ace marvel
CP
Tommy

Would lynch Ace Marvel next.

 

[T-Pein™]

My town core.

McNightstalker
Sister Abigail
Poyser
Lethal

Towns.

Phenom
Showtime.
Baldrick.

Scum leans

Red dragon
Wang

Scums

Oneiros
Ace marvel
CP
Tommy

Would lynch Ace Marvel next.

I feel like I am missing some random user.
If yes then they are null

 

[Comrade Khan]

Oneiros should be mostly cleared from Tommy's slip, why are ppl still scum reading him exactly?

 

[John McHenry]

My town core.

McNightstalker
Sister Abigail
Poyser
Lethal

Towns.

Phenom
Showtime.
Baldrick.

Scum leans

Red dragon
Wang

Scums

Oneiros
Ace marvel
CP
Tommy

Would lynch Ace Marvel next.

Why not go for the insta kill on Tommy?