"Glory, Hallelujah" | Barry Presents - The American Civil War - Mafia GAME THREAD

[Ekkologix]

Shit. Time to ISO Marvel and bus the shit out of him.

do u still scum read him?

 

[Sister Abigail]

Are they locked though? When did this become confirmed?

Unless there’s something I’ve missed where it’s said people can’t change their actions once they’ve been sent in, he’s just alerted mafia to him having a power role DURING night, and they can just decide to ice him. Night is literally the worst time to claim because you’re just giving mafia free information.

I am not a PR at all but have a specific reason why I said who I targeted. I'm not a huge fan of my role and doing my best to make it as effective as possible. What do you think the harm is of me doing this if I'm not a PR and really not that important of a role to Town at all.

 

[Comrade Khan]

well for me I felt Lethal also kind of gave away the game when he starting answering me with gifs and kind of no selling poyser when he started to question him a bit more seriously. he did a very similar thing when caught scum and then he went back to being pretty passive (until he got randomly angry and ppl not reading his defence but i see that as pretty NAI and likely mood dependant)

yes i still think the boy is scum lol

 

[Ekkologix]

It shocked to see me scum read, but shocked to see he's also scum reading Baldrick and and Captain Holt, two people I've sussed in D1. Not sure what team equity the three of them would have, especially since I actively made a case against Baldrick. Not sure why he is so antagonistic against you if he Town reads you. Disagree with Smark being Town. I'm wary of RDv2's slot as well and don't know how that slot gets read Town when RD has down nothing differently then his first slot and the only reason he was Town read in that first slot was because of a claim.

he doesnt have to scum read yall in a package

do u think all the players who u scum read can fit in a team?

 

[Ace Marvel]

I am not a PR at all but have a specific reason why I said who I targeted. I'm not a huge fan of my role and doing my best to make it as effective as possible. What do you think the harm is of me doing this if I'm not a PR and really not that important of a role to Town at all.

not being vanilla or goon = pr

whether is passive or not.

 

[Oneiros]

thanks.
1. can u tell me when did u make ur read of stalker?
2. GTH where do u place tpein and showtime in the list

i wud like to hear @Doddsy @CraigPelton @Tommy Bedlam @Oneiros @Sister Abigail @Captain Holt @T-Pein™ @Showtime @Baldrick @Tweet respond to this list

I have no problems with his list apart from Sister Abigail being scum, which I hardly disagree on as he has been one of my strongest town reads throughout the game.

I actually hate McNightstalker's reads but at the same I don't see why scum would give such bad scum reads.

I'm glad SA is targeting Smark whatever that ends up meaning.

 

[Comrade Khan]

But yeah @RDK point about lethal not being human when scum is 100% accurate, similar way he himself caught him in a recent game and the meta is pretty solid

 

[Ekkologix]

I have no problems with his list apart from Sister Abigail being scum, which I hardly disagree on as he has been one of my strongest town reads throughout the game.

I actually hate McNightstalker's reads but at the same I don't see why scum would give such bad scum reads.

I'm glad SA is targeting Smark whatever that ends up meaning.

if we flip tweet as scum right here and now who wud u gun for next?

 

[Comrade Khan]

not being vanilla or goon = pr

whether is passive or not.

i have to ask why yo uare wasting so much time on semantical arguments

 

[Ekkologix]

If I called you soft, it probably wasn't related to you joking about RD being scum. Where is this post?

I disagree that I went after RD 'super hard'. I had my suspicions early on about him, but that was it. Me and him arguing later on in D1 wasn't about my sussing him.

I have literally used The Supreme Alliance many, many, times, across a lot of different forums. It's a tactic I use for a variety of reasons, one of them because it's fun. You're not the first person who hasn't seen this tactic before who had called it scummy. That's actually one of the reasons I do it.

where do u stand on stalker after this interaction btw

 

[Mandalorian]

I am not a PR at all but have a specific reason why I said who I targeted. I'm not a huge fan of my role and doing my best to make it as effective as possible. What do you think the harm is of me doing this if I'm not a PR and really not that important of a role to Town at all.

You’re now saying that you’re not a power role which means that someone else is. Giving mafia information like that during night isn’t helpful to town.

 

[Ekkologix]

I think this reply has more Townie points, thoughts, then scum trying to shade me. McKnight might be wrong, but this makes me feel his less likely to be Wolf n

dem i need to spam refresh refresh refresh b4 i post i keep ninjai'ing myself

okay this is better

its all coming together

 

[RDK]

well for me I felt Lethal also kind of gave away the game when he starting answering me with gifs and kind of no selling poyser when he started to question him a bit more seriously. he did a very similar thing when caught scum and then he went back to being pretty passive (until he got randomly angry and ppl not reading his defence but i see that as pretty NAI and likely mood dependant)

yes i still think the boy is scum lol

This is what scum lethal does lol

I can pull receipts

But cop claim is ugh

 

[Poyser]

I respect mando’s consistency on the issue

 

[Comrade Khan]

I'm also curious as to why @Sister Abigail is randomly spouting off role targets etc before we have had a flip. It does kind of feel like a setup of some kind to a planned reveal. cant say im a big fan of that