"Glory, Hallelujah" | Barry Presents - The American Civil War - Mafia GAME THREAD

[Comrade Khan]

Setting aside how annoying I find him to play with, why are we lynching Ekko exactly?

lethal is lying, ekko doesnt have single vote

 

[Lethal]

its weird as af and i havent liked any of his further answers

would you also agree its unlikely he is paired with Mando or too early?

What else can I say? I like to run on gut feels and vibe, and I've vibed on you as town for majority of this phase. Your hostility isn't something I enjoy, but hey, it's not in my direction so I'm not that fussed. I would actively discourage it if I were scum with you. Just my take. You're within your means to play your game however you see fit.

Maybe I clutched at too many straws to validate my reason.

 

[Poyser]

its weird as af and i havent liked any of his further answers

would you also agree its unlikely he is paired with Mando or too early?

I don’t really see them being aligned no

 

[Mandalorian]

Not entirely sure what a wolf is, but I mentioned earlier that I was leaning scum on Man. We’re nearing the end of the day, and he’s one of the 2-3 people picking up votes.

Given you said a lot of this is based on our minimal experience playing together, I’m going to need you to bring up some examples.

 

[Sister Abigail]

Again there’s nothing here. Word salad is you’re saying a lot of things but you’re not really backing them up lol, just making generic statements. Where did Jeff show nerves? Why is admitting you made a mistake townie? If anything I’d say scum are infinitely more likely to stay calm under duress than town are lol. It can go both ways ofc but if you’ve never played with him before I’m not sure how you can be led to think he’s town here

i think he’s scum because he pushed two different narratives that he changed based on the agenda he was pushing at the time. He seemed pretty confident that if Jeff was town then he would be killed by mafia because they can’t do anything about his kill. This was after he had said he didn’t want Jeff to shoot the consensus target because scum could quite easily be the ones controlling it.

he also seemed fairly confident in jeff being scum, but then when I pointed out the contradiction he used the fact that he hadn’t voted jeff as a defence by saying he wasn’t sure enough on jeff to vote him, then said he could see scum leaving him alive to be an easy mislynch tomorrow.

I don’t think any of it tracks as somebody that’s trying to figure out the game. Rather it looks like somebody just being reactive and responding to pressure with attempted appeasements

I mean, I'm not going to find posts to back up my opinion of Mando, so I guess you'll just have to toss my salad. But seriously, I think there's just a couple of things you said that we disagree about fundamentally in Mafia about what Town or Wolf might do or how they might react in a situation, which is fine. I understand what you're saying about Mando's thoughts changing, but as I read his posts in real time, I thought he was just a player who explained himself poorly rather than on trying to change his narrative based on an agenda. I'm not overly attached to Mando here, but I'd rather shoot and lynch someone else this day.

 

[Poyser]

also, Abi just keeps rubbing me the wrong way. im just going to put it out there, i dont trust them and im really getting that time wasty paper push vibe

I don’t really like their points about Mando and asking me why i read him scum when I already have more than once (which he has 100% replied to) is definitely busywork stuff

but I might be confbiasing there a little bit too because of Mando

 

[Ace Marvel]

Imo desperado shot tweet

 

[Sister Abigail]

I'm saying Mando is null to me now and I'd rather Baldy or Tweet get shot before him. I'd rather go with a Baldy or Smark vote than a Mando one.

 

[Tweet]

lethal is lying, ekko doesnt have single vote

Head meets edge of table AGAIN

 

[Ekkologix]

Are you reading anything I post? Legit answer, I have never once said Jeff was mafia, no one, I said he is not playing with town best interests and now that the desperado claim is out, that I was right about is out, Jeff is now playing how I would expect a desperado to me play.

so you are just saying non sense

you said he is anti town to be exact. point still stays. u think he is playing anti town but still town. reason is weak


the second part makes no sense. at that time he claimed vig not desperado. how do u town read him for a wrong claim? he claimed vig but played as a desperadp according to u. from ur PoV u could NOT have known that Jeff was a desperado. where r u getting this confidence in the read from? tmi?

 

[Lethal]

also, Abi just keeps rubbing me the wrong way. im just going to put it out there, i dont trust them and im really getting that time wasty paper push vibe

PAPER PUSHING!

You just want to rubbed the right way. It'll make you less grumpy

"personal"?
where is this coming from? do you fail to see how its thread driven?

summing my interactions with him as personal is far from reality. i am now questioning how genuine is ur comprehension towards our posts in the game

When you're responses consist of multiple "reeeeeeees" to each other, yeah, I think it's personal and not helping game solve one bit.

Setting aside how annoying I find him to play with, why are we lynching Ekko exactly?

I mean, I tried one of their tactics to get him off this Jeff spat.

 

[Tweet]

Imo desperado shot tweet

enthusiastic kwehs

 

[Sister Abigail]

Not entirely sure what a wolf is, but I mentioned earlier that I was leaning scum on Man. We’re nearing the end of the day, and he’s one of the 2-3 people picking up votes.

Why is he scum to you?

 

[Ekkologix]

jeff has to absolutely shoot today. even more so as desperado

shoot tweet. this is final imo. at best u will die and we confirm tweet as town

alternatively shoot mando. do either

 

[Poyser]

you said he is anti town to be exact. point still stays. u think he is playing anti town but still town. reason is weak


the second part makes no sense. at that time he claimed vig not desperado. how do u town read him for a wrong claim? he claimed vig but played as a desperadp according to u. from ur PoV u could NOT have known that Jeff was a desperado. where r u getting this confidence in the read from? tmi?

Read the thread

how would he have TMI that Jeff is a desperado lmao