"Glory, Hallelujah" | Barry Presents - The American Civil War - Mafia GAME THREAD

[Comrade Khan]

more like double wagon!!!

so funny, I die laughter, I'm dead now.

get out

 

[Sister Abigail]

Your logical is skewed a bit. As town I’m not gonna suggest Jeff has to be scum as I don’t know for sure what he’ll flip, but if I was scum I might say Jeff is definitely scum let’s lynch him.

I think you're not understanding me. I'm saying you could have said that comment as scum and then if Jeff was mislynched been like 'tehe I thought this might have been a mislynch so silly me' and try to take some heat off if you try to vote Jeff out.

 

[Poyser]

I said that they can, as in they have the ability to, but doesn’t mean that they always will. Of course they can influence it, or at least try to, but when RD is now out there saying that he’s not even going to necessarily listen to whatever consensus is decided, that whole side of the argument collapses in on itself. Do you see what I’m getting at?

Why would I still be voting him today? Not crossed your mind that he could just be making it up? Like I’ve said - it’s a hard and frankly stupid claim to fake as scum - but he panicked enough to make a claim after getting two votes. So I’m not ruling it out that he’s BSing his claim because it’s not confirmed until he actually takes the shot. I don’t doubt the claim, though, but the claim itself is not alignment-indicative and I’d be surprised if anyone could convincingly argue otherwise.

Like I have also already said, he could be town and mafia could be wanting to leave him alive tonight so he’s lynched tomorrow because we’d have to assume he was mafia if he didn’t get killed after making that claim.

RD could well be town, but I’m not going sit here and pretend that him claiming what he did, when he did, was good town play because it categorically wasn’t for multiple reasons that ive



At the time of me responding to Sayer’s initial posts, my posts up to that point had been reserved. I wasn’t trying to say anything to the contrary.

However since then, I’d disagree. I’ve been putting out a couple of reads and I’ve discussed this entire RD thing at length more than once. In fact, I’d hardly describe the post where I basically told him to back off and stop telling me how to play my game as reserved at all. Would you?

I’ve also been back through my posts and cannot see anywhere where I’ve talked about the meta of anyone else I’ve played with before, can you point these out? You may be confusing me with someone else.

Your words were “if he’s town, I can’t see why mafia wouldn’t kill him tonight” and that statement doesn’t really marry up with your actions. In this post, you present a reason for why he might not be killed tonight of town in order to justify your vote that I called out, but before that you basically said if he’s not dead tonight then he’s not town, which would make trying to lynch him tonight a bit redundant.

i don’t really buy that you really think he could be BSing his daykill tbh lol, what would be the end game there?
Nobody is arguing it was good town play btw. Tho that doesn’t necessarily make it scummy.

as for the meta stuff, this is the post I was thinking of:

I can kind of see what Sayer is saying, but to be honest he’s played with me long enough to know that I’m traditionally busier at the weekend. That being said, I am leaning town on him at the moment. I can say that out of understanding of his usual game, though.

As for others that I’m not as familiar with, I’m afraid I can’t say too much at the moment. I don’t feel great about Red Dragon, as I got a feeling that some of his posting was a bit ‘throwing things at the wall and see what sticks’. Don’t know if that’s his style or a way to get some bites out of people. I stand by when I said I didn’t understand his confusion with mine and Smark’s clearly non-serious votes on OJ, though.

Although I’ll concede that it wasn’t as bad as my memory thought it was but it was a fair amount of meta talk about you and him, and then read him town without any explanation at all other than that you’re saying it “out of understanding of his usual game”

 

[Ace Marvel]

Town: Poyser, Switcheroo, Dark Pink Dragon

easy game.

 

[Comrade Khan]

who is switcheroo

 

[Smart Marx]

I think you're not understanding me. I'm saying you could have said that comment as scum and then if Jeff was mislynched been like 'tehe I thought this might have been a mislynch so silly me' and try to take some heat off if you try to vote Jeff out.

I could sure, but as town I also said it because the only thing I was certain of is they wouldn’t both be town.

That’s changed now, though.

 

[Smart Marx]

who is switcheroo

I am, I assume.

 

[Sister Abigail]

I could sure, but as town I also said it because the only thing I was certain of is they wouldn’t both be town.

That’s changed now, though.

Let's move forward from all of this.

Who are you scum leans right now?

 

[Poyser]

I was only planning to counter claim lol, did I?

I don't have a kill, i just assume the what kind of conditions were needed for Jeff to do the kill.

I don’t understand what you’re saying here

 

[Ace Marvel]

I could sure, but as town I also said it because the only thing I was certain of is they wouldn’t both be town.

That’s changed now, though.

I know I'm new here, but we all know the play. I'm not that naive.
lol

 

[Poyser]

It’s past 5am. I’m off to bed. Probably not around much today as it’s grand final day. Think SuperBowl but in Australia

Go the panthers

 

[Smart Marx]

Let's move forward from all of this.

Who are you scum leans right now?

Tweet, and CP, possibly. But I don’t have any strong leans atm.

Jeff was sounding fishy for a minute, but I’m ok on him right now.

 

[Ace Marvel]

I don’t understand what you’re saying here

if you get it, you get it
if you don't, you don't
if you know, you know
and if you don't know, then I just feel bad for you
like i can't explain it like I don't have the vocabulary
to sit here and explain like you get the vibe or you don't get the vibe

 

[Sister Abigail]

Tweet, and CP, possibly. But I don’t have any strong leans atm.

Jeff was sounding fishy for a minute, but I’m ok on him right now.

CP has three posts. We're forty two pages into this game and that's a name you drop?

Why Tweet?

 

[Poyser]

if you get it, you get it
if you don't, you don't
if you know, you know
and if you don't know, then I just feel bad for you
like i can't explain it like I don't have the vocabulary
to sit here and explain like you get the vibe or you don't get the vibe

Out