After looking at both and having a very hard time deciding, I have to give my vote to Booty. I love Billy's piece, particularly the FUNK in the background and the blending of Clay, however its just a little dark for my liking. Booty's piece just explodes out of the screen at you, which is kind of how Clay's character is meant to be. I felt it perfectly captured the essence of the character and it looks beautiful to boot.
Excellent work from both of you however, and I can see Billy doing well in SOTW whenever we finally get that back up and running.