If she is lying, that is really telling of her character. This is not something to joke about or lie about.
And I will admit it, we can't say 100% that she is not lying about it because none of us know her personally nor were there.
UNLESS she did go see the doctor right after it happened and has documentation of this. It would be silly to bring it up 10 year later if it was a lie.
I think she may have seen the doctor right after as well. Or I may have misread that.
Either way, women do/have lied about this before and I have 0 respect for them but you can't discount this as being a lie right off the bat simply because other women have done it.
I'll tell you one thing though, this should not be a topic that is debated about over it being the truth or not but that is the kind of sick world we live in. It is not my place to judge though. Just a damn shame.
edit----------->
I googled a bit on her, as I was not watching wrestling from 2005-2008. She did Playboy/porn prior to WWE and was involved in a high-class escort service, selling her body for $25,000 prior to and in to her WWE career.
"According to the Rolling Stones peice, the FBI monitored e-mails between Massaro and "Bella Models." The e-mails are from 2004, regarding transportation arrangements. The monitored e-mails were used to help build towards a search warrant on the ring leader of the escort service, Michelle "Nici" Braun. The search warrant was finally executed during a raid of Braun's home in October 2007."
Based on her past and what she did while in the WWE, I can see why people would believe her to be a liar but just because she was a hooker, it doesn't mean she is immune to rape either. Then again people may argue that she put her self in position by offering her body in exchange for money.
My guess would be that someone may have seen her "services" online over there and maybe she was going to do them for the money but something went wrong OR the guy simply took it upon himself. This can be the reason why WWE wanted her to keep quiet. They didn't want people speculating that women they hire within the company are escorts or hookers. This can be another reason she also didn't say anything too... cause of her past with the FBI and being an escort, maybe she thought the courts wouldn't taker her seriously.
Just wanted to share that so maybe people can get a better understanding of the situation. Again, if it is true - Shame on WWE for not supporting her, if she is lying though, shame on her.