Doctor Who Mafia - Game Thread

[Marty McFourth]

I'd give the second HM to Poyser, if it was me.

He really did play a good scum game and was still managing to talk his way out of some things even when his lynch was looking obvious and concrete.

Mitch I feel is a good choice as well as he came in pretty clutch with that info on Poyser and he played Vig smart.

 

[Alco]

My record's on the rise again

 

[Alco]

Oh and great job TFW and Phenom! Hell of a performance!

 

[Chris]

Didn't even have to vote nice

Thanks for the game Ace

 

[Alco]

Chris you gotta help me, man. I legit always read you scum

 

[Ace]

So as discussed in dead QT the game was a mix of some mistakes by me (having a scum tracker in agame with town watchers and motion detectors is prolly not a great idea, and obviously giving Phenom CPs name was a botch),

but also of some bad luck for scum - T-Pein being a plum, SK getting shot N1 who would have likely whittled down town guys particualrly as scum started looking like they were destined to lose, and scum janitoring the mason.

Was rusty as this is my first game hosted in quite a while but I think overall the balance wasn't truly horrific and next game i host i will polish up the rough edges.

 

[Ace]

thanks everyone for playing - good job to town for the blowout

 

[Marty McFourth]

Even though I suspected CP before his confirm, he's one of the people that really got me to look in to Poyser again and I was pretty much following his words upon his death. So yeah, good catch CP.

I think I may have pushed on Doddsy if not for the cop confirm. Glad I didn't, as he sent me the screwdriver the next day.

@Ace What would have happened if Doddsy reached me while my weak JOAT was still active?

 

[Ace]

Even though I suspected CP before his confirm, he's one of the people that really got me to look in to Poyser again and I was pretty much following his words upon his death. So yeah, good catch CP.

I think I may have pushed on Doddsy if not for the cop confirm. Glad I didn't, as he sent me the screwdriver the next day.

@Ace What would have happened if Doddsy reached me while my weak JOAT was still active?

You would have got roles every night rather than every odd, and cop and bg shots would have been added to the rotation of random abilities.

 

[Ace]

after much deliberation poyser gets the second HM

 

[Poyser]

I don't know what to say Ace, thank you. This really means a lot. I really enjoyed the game and I felt that we all worked together really well as a town.

Sadly I had a few blunders in my play, I should have pushed on Big Man and Grim way harder. Poyser had me fooled majority of the game. I didn't like his entrance but he did well to bring me on side, his performance was good. The Mitch info is what really came in clutch for selling me on Poyser as 100% scum.

This is probably the most effort I've put in to a town game in a few years and I was right on most things which is a first for me. I'm really happy with how I did, I just need more confidence to push.

You fucking killed it bruh

 

[Marty McFourth]

PoyserPerson was signed in when posted
04-26-2021
06:29 AM ET (US)
I cant give any good reason for why Im still trying at this point other than to fuck with TFW and give him a crisis of confidence for my own amusement lmaooo

 

[Poyser]

I'd give the second HM to Poyser, if it was me.

He really did play a good scum game and was still managing to talk his way out of some things even when his lynch was looking obvious and concrete.

Mitch I feel is a good choice as well as he came in pretty clutch with that info on Poyser and he played Vig smart.

Man I dont even know why I kept trying at the end at all lmao, it was over the minute phenom claimed but I just wanted to at least give something to make it interesting. Think I said in the scum qt I was essentially doing it just to give you a crisis of confidence

Just wanted to make it interesting for you!

 

[Marty McFourth]

You fucking killed it bruh

Judging from your posts in the Dead QT I was being really annoying going on about Grim and Big Man constantly

You did well to keep bouncing my thoughts in different directions. I'm one of those people that always considers multiple scenarios. So even though I felt pretty confident on those two, Chris and Tweet being up in the air gave me pause.

If not for Grim's reaction to me and his Chevy interaction, I like to think I would have kept pushing on that a big stronger but I abandoned that read for a bit. As I said, my play definitely had some flaws but impossible to be right on everything, so I'll not beat myself up over it.

 

[Alco]

the moment Barry literally threw the towel by talking about his own sign-ups