Doctor Who Mafia - Game Thread

[Mitch Buchannon]

What of it, I lynched scum

You know what I said last I didn’t think it was a bus but now I think it’s entirely plausible. It could be totally plausible if say y’all decided T-Pein was gonna be a huge distraction and decided to get rid of him early. This post reeks of mafia trying to take credit for the lynch of a fellow mafia.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[Evans]

I'll likely start playing fo realzies d2 but until then another piece of juicy WIFOM

I've been wanting to draw scum for a while now to see whether I've improved or not, ask yourself if this "performance" fits someone who would love to play scum rn

This is a text book example of “appeal to reason”

hmm

 

[Chloe B]

But since you played with me as scum, I want you to give an honest assessment of what playing with me was like

Still waiting for your response @Chevy

 

[Poyser]

Think barry is a fair shout, he hasn't commented anything other than how annoying t-pein is lol unless i've missed something

 

[Poyser]

Even mitch thinks flay was bussing lmao? Does Mitch have much experience with flay? Seems like such an odd conclusion for him in particular to draw.

 

[Poyser]

From memory I don't even think they've played together ever

 

[Poyser]

You know what I said last I didn’t think it was a bus but now I think it’s entirely plausible. It could be totally plausible if say y’all decided T-Pein was gonna be a huge distraction and decided to get rid of him early. This post reeks of mafia trying to take credit for the lynch of a fellow mafia.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

I dont get this, he was replying to you saying he's been a big distraction, he didn't proactively try and take credit for it at all. Or at least not in the post you're quoting. I'd get pretty defensive about it if I lynched scum from my first few posts in the game and then somebody said I've been a distraction. It's not like Flay made himself the distraction is it??

 

[Evans]

You've played with me as scum, do you honestly think that I destroy my own team mate like that WITHOUT any prompt in the thread for my own benefit and perception in the thread?

The two posts I quoted I believe are your prompts.

I actually believe T-Pein didn’t read his PM and just started posting. That would explain why you gave him the heads up of him being the next lynch.

and you ended up just saying fuck it and took the opportunity to look good. Something I believe you would absolutely do as scum.

much like your fake info on Odo where you ummed and ahhed in the QT and waited for us (where we were like yeah sure) and a smaller scale where you asked about faking your usage on Poyser N1 and went ahead with it anyway.

I enjoyed playing with you as scum and I don’t think I’d be comfortable enough concrete reading you as scum based off your meta but I think I understand you enough to comfortably say yeah, you’d bus T-Pein early to avoid him fucking you and your team

 

[Poyser]

The two posts I quoted I believe are your prompts.

I actually believe T-Pein didn’t read his PM and just started posting. That would explain why you gave him the heads up of him being the next lynch.

and you ended up just saying fuck it and took the opportunity to look good. Something I believe you would absolutely do as scum.

much like your fake info on Odo where you ummed and ahhed in the QT and waited for us (where we were like yeah sure) and a smaller scale where you asked about faking your usage on Poyser N1 and went ahead with it anyway.

I enjoyed playing with you as scum and I don’t think I’d be comfortable enough concrete reading you as scum based off your meta but I think I understand you enough to comfortably say yeah, you’d bus T-Pein early to avoid him fucking you and your team

How can you possibly still believe t-pein didn't read his role pm? I've already debunked this lol. There's no way he randomly through out a fake lie detector claim without looking at what his actual role was

 

[Poyser]

the fact that he fake claimed makes it very obvious he knew he was scum

 

[Evans]

How can you possibly still believe t-pein didn't read his role pm? I've already debunked this lol. There's no way he randomly through out a fake lie detector claim without looking at what his actual role was

I feel it’s more likely he didn’t read it to start the game, not that he didn’t read it at all.

 

[Poyser]

I feel it’s more likely he didn’t read it to start the game, not that he didn’t read it at all.

Why though? What reason do you have to believe this at all lol

 

[Grimoire Lenin]

I read through all of Day 1 and decided "fuck it, I'm not even gonna bother gleaning anything from it." T-Pein was such a distraction and an annoyance that I'm not re-reading it. I'm playing for the present, and I really don't give a shit if people sus me or not.

I think Magic's read on Flay is just completely wrong, and the idea that scum would just lynch their godfather so willingly, despite the fact he was being lynched for being annoying. I don't think anyone even actually read him scum, just annoying and needed to go.

 

[Evans]

I am not bussing Chloe btw

“He’s bussing me”

 

[Chloe B]

The two posts I quoted I believe are your prompts.

I actually believe T-Pein didn’t read his PM and just started posting. That would explain why you gave him the heads up of him being the next lynch.

and you ended up just saying fuck it and took the opportunity to look good. Something I believe you would absolutely do as scum.

much like your fake info on Odo where you ummed and ahhed in the QT and waited for us (where we were like yeah sure) and a smaller scale where you asked about faking your usage on Poyser N1 and went ahead with it anyway.

I enjoyed playing with you as scum and I don’t think I’d be comfortable enough concrete reading you as scum based off your meta but I think I understand you enough to comfortably say yeah, you’d bus T-Pein early to avoid him fucking you and your team

You remember the circumstances in which I did that right? We had no even night kill so I thought to take advantage of an obvious disadvantage. Of course Juice fucked us with revealing that mechanic in the flip but you have to admit it was a viable idea.

Where was the disadvantage for scum in regards to T-Pein in the thread? People had difficulty reading him so as a team mate I could have easily let him slip but I made a decent case on him. And people agreed added their own thoughts on him.