Death on the Nile [A Detective Adventure Part II]

[John McHenry]

What’s making you hesitant here?

I'm buying the defense he's answered every question, he hasn't backtracked, he's even given us his role that it typically scum from my reading why give us all this info ? Why not make up a different role? He could still be scum, but we've also yet to hear from @Rawhide.

Who has the benefit of not having any reads on him whatsoever.

And I still have SA as null

With a game like this where everything is wrong I'm not confident this is the right move yet I want to throughly sus it out first.

 

[Ekkologix]

If I get some time, I'll look at this posts again.

Like me, you were pretty gung ho on RDK. What are your thoughts now that he's flipped Town?

my thoughts r wtf was he doing

 

[Ekkologix]

@Tweet @Switchblade @Lethal Jade thoughs on abis read on u?

 

[Ekkologix]

Why Lethal over everything we have going today?

can you summerize in ur own words whats "everything we have going today?"

if you have a particular direction u can say it right away. dont need to be vague about it

 

[Mandalorian]

@Red Dragon do you mind reminding me who you sent your list to on night two please?

 

[Tweet]

@Tweet @Switchblade @Lethal Jade thoughs on abis read on u?

Me likey

 

[Smart Marx]

can you summerize in ur own words whats "everything we have going today?"

if you have a particular direction u can say it right away. dont need to be vague about it

We have Man that’s been listed in a Carol as potentially being mafia and a dead cop that vot f for him out of the gate on day 2.

Then there’s TP getting scum results on myself and Jeff.

We have two night kills to analyze too. You have any reason to suspect Lethal over anyone else?

My choice would be Man. That needs to be solved.

 

[Tweet]

Can we please lynch the guy who was apparently red checked by the actual Cop

 

[Ekkologix]

13 players alive

likely 4-6 mafia

meaning our chances to hit outside of the 3 names r honestly more or less the same, if not even better

the only advantage of hitting in the 3 is that if we hit mafia there we can clear the other 2. thats obviously assuming jeff's ability is legit

17 players
2 survivors, 11 town, 4 mafia makes most sense i guess? its a bit too big of a mafia number considering how fked up our cops r. maybe only 3 mafia and 12 town

anyway 3-4 mafia is my best guess. lets say worst case scenario 4 mafia


we have:

jeff's result says 1 / 3 mando holt SA is scum

that leaves 3 / 10 players outside of the result as scum. one of these 10 players is an indie so we have basically 3/9 scum outside of the result and 1/3 inside of it, assuming its a team of 4


tl;dr if this math checks out, we have the same chance lynching outside the 3 names as we have lynching inside of it. anyone asking me why am i voting lethal when i scum read them already need to find better content

 

[Smart Marx]

Can we please lynch the guy who was apparently red checked by the actual Cop

If you mean Man, that’s where my head’s at.

 

[Mandalorian]

Can we please lynch the guy who was apparently red checked by the actual Cop

Can you explain where the apparently comes from please?

Are you suggesting that Doddsy got a mafia ping on me and then made up a weak reason to sus me to justify a vote? Why not just come out with the information?

 

[Smart Marx]

Can you explain where the apparently comes from please?

Are you suggesting that Doddsy got a mafia ping on me and then made up a weak reason to sus me to justify a vote? Why not just come out with the information?

Some cops prefer to get a few usages out before they claim their roles so they try to subtly sway a wagon first.

 

[Ekkologix]

We have Man that’s been listed in a Carol as potentially being mafia and a dead cop that vot f for him out of the gate on day 2.

am i stopping u from voting him?

Then there’s TP getting scum results on myself and Jeff.

irrelevant. from ur PoV u shud know this result is wrong if u r town. why r u even bringing this up like its something relevant? are u not town huh??

 

[Smart Marx]

You guys rushed last day phase and we see how that turned out. No reason to not get some discussion in.

 

[Smart Marx]

am i stopping u from voting him?


irrelevant. from ur PoV u shud know this result is wrong if u r town. why r u even bringing this up like its something relevant? are u not town huh??

I know I’m town, but YOU don’t. I also don’t know if Jeff is town, but I heavily believe him to be because of TP and his own role, but again YOU don’t know that. You’ve brushed past like 6 pieces of info to throw a vote on someone completely out of left field. I’m asking YOU why.