Death on the Nile [A Detective Adventure Part II]

[Kiffy Lube]

I went for a smoke. Do I gotta read all of this?

 

[Tweet]

tpein? ya pretty sure hes just the cop that always gets scum results since he copped smark scum last night . he also came in here saying he doesnt trust his results anymore

Oh yeah, I trust you to be town at this point and the inverse Cop is already gone, so he'd have to be the Cop that always gets guilty results.

 

[Comrade Khan]

Tho if I really think about it, what's to tell us that all Cops are town in this kinda setup? One of them might easily be a fake for scum, it certainly doesn't hurt the balance once we've established that the Cop results are varying degrees of reliable. I think one Cop being scum would be more balanced than up to four Cops all being town and being auto confirmed.

This is all speculation tho

guessin ur not the 4th cop either?

 

[Mandalorian]

Should add that if Pein does get all scum results then there’s still the possibility that Jeff and/or Smark are scum. Neither should be considered clear through that mechanic.

 

[Comrade Khan]

I think i should be cleared on play alone by now

 

[Comrade Khan]

@Tweet thoughts on mando claiming driver w no usage?

 

[Tweet]

Um dude I'm the one who got McHenry to reveal the names. He and Jeff were playing a game of cluedo about the whole singing of songs lol.

And by Jeff's claim he says he visits someone and sings a carol, and they receive 3 names from the host.

Sister, Sayer and you. So, if Jeff is to be believed (and I do based on my town read of him), then that's a 1 in 3 shot that we take. The vig could do a solid tonight and then we go the other 2 if it's unsuccessful.

Just my 2 cents

Idk why but cluedo made me snort

 

[Ekkologix]

so not only did tpein not die, but he was also not roleblocked

if there is a naive cop they rly need to come out

 

[Tweet]

@Tweet thoughts on mando claiming driver w no usage?

That's obviously a NAI role, and having no usage is either for real, or his way of trying to avoid giving away any more info. Either way it's nothing that would explain away a red check on him so

 

[Comrade Khan]

So ive aaked for clarification and of the 3 names 1 is mafia. I asked if it means the other 2 have to be town. Juice repeated that 1 is mafia. Just food for thought re:indy hunting

 

[Ekkologix]

I feel like Jeff's list is probably more secure than Tpein's supposed check. Mechanical stuff should maybe be taken with a grain of salt right now. However, knowing I'm Town, if Jeff's list is right, than Mando or Holt is scum. Holt hasn't other than saying he needs to redeem himself and disappearing. I think Mando has taken some heat here as well from other people. I'd rather vote Mando before Holt since the latter is not around.

I think we have some fuckery here. I think Tpein could be Cop or could be lying, but I won't vote Jeff next. RDK is hella suss. I think we start there.

SA doesnt seem afraid of solving the list first which looks good on him tbh

 

[Comrade Khan]

So basically if any of the flip town it only clears the two being non mafia but still be can b non town

 

[Tweet]

so not only did tpein not die, but he was also not roleblocked

if there is a naive cop they rly need to come out

I wouldn't have said this btw because in case we got a misconception on our hands and there's only three out of those four Cop variants in the game, scum could easily fake claim the fourth without us suspecting a thing, but only if they think of it themselves.

 

[John McHenry]

So ive aaked for clarification and of the 3 names 1 is mafia. I asked if it means the other 2 have to be town. Juice repeated that 1 is mafia. Just food for thought re:indy hunting

Did he say mafia or villan?

 

[John McHenry]

Did he say mafia or villan?

The quote I got specifically said Villain. And we know we have a train aligned.