Death on the Nile [A Detective Adventure Part II]

[Smart Marx]

But I did get a Carol also if this role is typically town...yeah lost

He’s now hedging his bushes by the fence.

 

[Smart Marx]

So by Jeffs logic forming lynching v1 me he should be lynched for the info however I believe he's the caroler, I also think tpein is some sort of cop. Imo it's more believable mafia would screw with a result on Jeff due to his caliber of player. However he could still be train?

Honestly hoping any towns with night powers go for people on the list given.

Holt is a wash he's made 1 post hard to sus that out so the focus turns to sa and Mando. 50/50 getting it right as inactive as holt is him being the scum seems bad for a clue. Not clearing him just a stronger argument to go at the other 2.

What even is this post?

After saying info shouldn’t be trusted, no less.

 

[Smart Marx]

All my humor gets read as scum

Is that what it is.

 

[Smart Marx]

LOL that'd make me super sus to them

Are you sus yet? You definitely care now.

This post is just me being a dick. Not case related lol

 

[Smart Marx]

Hard choice at this juncture. If tpein claims he copped one from yesterday's list do you believe the result?

These flip flops really don’t feel genuine.

Though, for the record, mafia probably aren’t sure of what the cop situation was, either, but this definitely feels like intentionally adding more gas to the fire.

 

[Smart Marx]

also @Mandalorian

i feel we should talk about @Sister Abigail since shes in the three, and holt is awol. regardless if you believe my role or not, whats your feel on that slot?

First interaction I see and he’s asking Mando if SA is scum.

 

[Smart Marx]

If @Captain Holt was participating that'd help a lot.

@Mandalorian You're claiming town so then is SA scum?

Wrong quote before somehow lol

 

[Smart Marx]

I can see not being fully supportive of Jeff, I've gone back and forth. But would I get a message from a host saying someone is "villain" (can't have that coming back to bite me in the but again) (yes salty)(end mini rant I'll let it go like elsa now) if they weren't? And tampering with a 1/3 result seems a little odd, nobody else has claimed caroler so he's got to be some form of the role. Unless somehow someone else can frame one of the results but jesus that's a lot of weird framing and wrong answers etc. So therefore I believe the results have to be legit.

And as I said before I don't think it'd be smart from juice to give us Captain Holt that way.

Very curious interaction between McKnight and man where he finally stopped hedging on Jeff and even that not completely. Like he needed help coming down from his life 1 and ease into 2.

 

[Smart Marx]

Both him and Mando heavily talking about the Holt and sa slots which is very easy for them to do considering the Carol implications.

everybody should’ve been as well but seeing Mando and Henry specifically doing this from my perspective looks bad when I know the McKenry shot Jeff.

 

[Smart Marx]

Yeah my problem is I read Jeff as town, but I did also see him as indie. That info then legitimized him. I don't see him getting a role like that he can screw with. His role seems designed to support the cop (as we already had the cop variant) not undermine it. So how was Ace's result wrong is the big question. Because I would think that if it was tampered with buy scum (and not mechanics) then Tpein is scum. But we don't know so we can't do anything about Tpein. I just think Jeff role has to be legit.

This is contradictory to his earlier posts.

 

[Smart Marx]

Wouldn't it be better to have Tpein checking the names? That way if Jeff is 100% legit we can keep getting info as where a lynch cut's the information?

Why would McHenry want TP checking any names if he believes Jeff now? He knows he copped Jeff as mafia? This reeks.

 

[Smart Marx]

Mando had a good point why hasn't of all people @Captain Holt been repped yet?

Agreeing with Mando about the Holt slot.

 

[Smart Marx]

Nope I was kinda expecting one but I got nothing.

This is where he claims he didn’t get a song.

He’s either lying or he was killing that night.

If I blocked Jeff that night, I’d certainly not claim no results on that night. I’d just say I didn’t see anyone.

 

[Smart Marx]

vote mandalorian

McHenry knows where the wind is gonna blow here after Doddsy flipped earlier. He even posted before this that Doddsy didn’t say anything due to TP. A perfect shield to look good off this inevitable flip.

 

[Smart Marx]

He may have suspected that he was a cop with a weird variant and entertained tpein was legit. So I'd agree with this.

This post here.