Yeah I get that, it's probably because the Rumble is still one of the best PPV's but as soon as the PPV starts to come around, you look at the people who are out injured and see if they are in line to return and then you kind of start just expecting them to show up.I think Rumble pops work so well mostly bc you can have so many entrants that are meh and then that one time the buzzer hits and it's Edge (which was also kinda expected by that point), you still go nuts for it.
Now if you had her show up during the Womens match after the Rumble match had already happened however..