Barry Presents: Whodunnit 2: The West Smithton Sagas GAME THREAD

[Banez]

So worried night 1 you're gonna die, but here you are. Didn't seemed worried at all night 2.

 

[Kim Jong Umb]

I would wait for mass claim until tomorrow. I think it's more then likely mafia will see whoever's is SK and spin it to try and lynch them stating that the person is indy.

 

[NotBrutus]

Idk what you want me to say I go with my gut for reads I have nothing else to go by for it if something feels off to me it feels off so I'm not sure what you want.

My guess is there is two mafia left. I could see a indy but I def feel like one of three I said are mafia

Don't mean to double team but:
Gut aside, any scum reads based off of play?

@NotBrutus what's your thoughts on Odo Lethal and Mitch and now I see your post on phenom

Odo is town, I think Lethal is town but I'm not a fan of him nitpicking certain posts and no selling after they've been replied to, his read (specifically on Phen0m) gives me pause. As Odo said, Mitch's posts looks like his usual self, but that also doesn't help that I don't know how a scum Mitch would play.

 

[NotBrutus]

Why do people read Rugrat as town?

Guy is troll in both alignments.

So what's your read on him boyyo?

 

[Kim Jong Umb]

Don't mean to double team but:
Gut aside, any scum reads based off of play?



Odo is town, I think Lethal is town but I'm not a fan of him nitpicking certain posts and no selling after they've been replied to, his read (specifically on Phen0m) gives me pause. As Odo said, Mitch's posts looks like his usual self, but that also doesn't help that I don't know how a scum Mitch would play.

I mean my gut is 2/3 Poyser, Smark was wrong bout Tweetum. So I mean IDK what else to say.

 

[Odo]

So Banez, you going with ‘Why are you alive’ spec?

You sure?

Cause you’re firmly back in play after Haza and Smarks flips

 

[Lethal]

Well I'm here at the start of day. Should I park my vote somewhere so Lethal doesn't sus me with his dreaded vote list?

I'd probably agree with most of this list but what're you leaning scum about OMB? He did nail Smark as scum. Is it more of a case of "I know he's scum because I'm scum'? Also, why do you have Phen0m as a town read? What's the reasoning? He had a large influx of content, sure but what's he done more than Magic?

The "vote-list" is there so patterns can be observed. If you don't want to use it, that's your deal.

Yeah, OMB was riding Smark's dick hard but Smark was being town read from a lot of people, so maybe it was a bus of sorts in the event OMB got whacked which made Smark look even better?

As for PHEN0M, I have a very good reason to now read him town

That little bit from phenom makes him solid town?

Yeah no buys.

vote lethal

So your rage has subsided now that you're off the block for a moment.

I have strong reasoning to buy PHEN0M as town.

I would wait for mass claim until tomorrow. I think it's more then likely mafia will see whoever's is SK and spin it to try and lynch them stating that the person is indy.

Why are you introducing SK spec when that's not a priority atm? Seems needless distraction and scrambling.

 

[Odo]

I mean if you want an actual answer, they don’t know who the protective role is, or if there’s a watcher as well

do better

 

[Odo]

Lethal

 

[Lethal]

I'm hoping that's at Banez?

 

[Banez]

I mean if you want an actual answer, they don’t know who the protective role is, or if there’s a watcher as well

do better

I can do better.

You're alive because probably you are reading remaining scum town. And who wouldn't want to keep you alive if your reads are so off.

 

[Odo]

I can do better.

You're alive because probably you are reading remaining scum town. And who wouldn't want to keep you alive if your reads are so off.

Well, it’s a good job I’m resetting my reads isn’t it then

 

[Odo]

So er, what was the point of that conversation

 

[Banez]

Well, it’s a good job I’m resetting my reads isn’t it then

Go ahead.

I dont mind if ppl lynch me, i'm a viable mislynch candidate. better get me out from game now than later.

So if you guys can't come up with anything, feel free.

 

[Odo]

I'm hoping that's at Banez?

yep

tip: your reason isn’t as good as you think it is. Just think about it given the state of the game

do you have any other reads, other than me you feel this strong about?