Barry Presents: Whodunnit 2: The West Smithton Sagas GAME THREAD

[Mitch Buchannon]

did you not really believe it last time?

I mean of course I believed it, but obviously I was wrong

 

[Grimoire Lenin]

@Rugrat has replaced @Big Man ​

 

[Mitch Buchannon]

Mitch I’d appreciate it if you referred more to guys who weren’t ws before we migrated over, they are pretty much all you talk about

That's fair, I think I always look at OMB because him and I have played at a different forum together for years

 

[Tweet]

@Rugrat has replaced @Big Man ​

Welcome to the game you S M U R F !

 

[Tweet]

That's fair, I think I always look at OMB because him and I have played at a different forum together for years

Okay so far so good, I wanna encourage you to move out of your comfort zone a little and try to tell me what you think of Jeff, Banez and Raidokken please.

 

[Rugrat]

Okay so far so good, I wanna encourage you to move out of your comfort zone a little and try to tell me what you think of Jeff, Banez and Raidokken please.

Once he’s told you his thoughts on Jeff, Banez and Raidokken can you try to tell me what you think of Jeff, Banez and Raidokken please?

 

[Tweet]

Once he’s told you his thoughts on Jeff, Banez and Raidokken can you try to tell me what you think of Jeff, Banez and Raidokken please?

Sure

silly smurf

 

[Tweet]

I mean of course I believed it, but obviously I was wrong

Obviously huh?

 

[Mitch Buchannon]

1. Jeffatron - I feel Jeff has played a very town game
2. Big Man/Rugrat - we will find out
3. Raidokken - still leaning scum on Haza, everything he posts feels like fluff
4. Judas Iscariot - feeling a lot better on OMB, plus he softed VT
5. Mitch Perfect - I know I'm town
6. Odo - still feeling good on Odo
7. PHEN0M - not feeling great on N0M, he hasn't gotten into red territory yet but his posts are not likable
8. Showtime - same feelings as N0M
9. Alco
10. Darth Lethal - I have not felt good about Lethal, his fight with KIF last night kinda felt like something him and KIF came up with
11. Banez - pretty conflicted on Banez, but I'm leaning more mafia than town. His posts have not been good.
12. Mr.Tweetums - Tweet is starting to look better to me
14. Uncle Larry - I feel KIF is mafia, he's kind of trying but hasn't actually contributed. His fight with Lethal felt fake. Him siding with Poyser then throwing shade at him felt like he was creating separation.
15. NotBrutus - Brutus has been strange. After the last few games I don't know if I can trust him. I'm leaning more town but I'm not sure on him
17. Broken God - I still feel he's played a pretty town game

 

[Rugrat]

Let’s get some votes on Banez

Vote Banez

 

[Tweet]

Oh yeah I more or less instantly forgot there was the VT thing with OMB. Leaning towards that one being real for now tbh, and also feel considerably less strange about Mitch saying that he was obviously wrong before.

 

[Tweet]

Alright now that you (Mitch) make a reads list like that I also remember you made a similar one during d1. I'll compare those in a minute but for now:

I think Jeff is likely town although he feels a little reserved at times.

I have little doubt that Banez is scum and that we're gonna lynch him to end this phase.

There's nothing about Hazas play that would make me lean town in his direction, he seems to be his usual contrarian-cause-I-can self and not much else.

 

[RDK]

Heading out for the night!

Vote: Banez!

 

[NotBrutus]

That was a quick reread. He looks to be playing the game so that would warrant a tentative town lean, but last game has shown that as non-town he has the same tendencies as Sky in that he more or less inevitably falls back into his non-town meta as the game progresses, so that's one guy to keep an eye on.

So what exactly is my "town meta"? Haven't you gone on record saying it's hard to read me?

I don't disagree with that assessment, tweet

What part of the posts don't you disagree with?

 

[NotBrutus]

Bet Sky was the vig.

What makes you think this?