Barry Presents: Whodunnit 2: The West Smithton Sagas GAME THREAD

[Smart Marx]

First off a vote within the first hour doesn't necessarily mean I think you're scum, just that I wanna see what happens if I vote you.

My thought process was that much like Smark, I got the feeling that you were looking to direct attention literally anywhere but yourself, and your vote on Mitch seemed like more of that, but then I read your reason for voting him and remembered that you caught Lethal pretty much the same way in Game Show Mafia and thought maybe I oughta give you a chance especially after being dead wrong about you early on two games ago. Also you voting Mitch after his first post is in line with what you frequently do, which is going after weaker players early on and see how they handle the pressure.

I was weary of this, but I do like this post.

 

[Poyser]

That post seems almost too sensible for tweet

 

[Smart Marx]

That post seems almost too sensible for tweet

Coached response?

Tweet's come a long way tbf.

 

[Tweet]

That post seems almost too sensible for tweet

I know I've been an idiot two games ago but I don't think I'm a guy where saying reasonable things suggests coaching?

Have I been relegated to tier 5 without being consulted or something?

 

[RDK]

 

[Tweet]

I was weary of this, but I do like this post.

Weary of what?

 

[Smart Marx]

Weary of what?

The initial switch from a vote to following his vote. But I liked the response you gave me.

I still think his vote on Mitch is iffy at best, though.

 

[RDK]

Barry made me town in one of his games for once, one of the good guys

 

[Poyser]

I know I've been an idiot two games ago but I don't think I'm a guy where saying reasonable things suggests coaching?

Have I been relegated to tier 5 without being consulted or something?

It’s just that I couldn’t get this kind of reasonable discussion out of you when you were tunnelling me last game
the way I phrased it was a joke, but you’re obviously self aware enough as scum to know that id pick up on it if you didn’t learn from your mistake. Of course, that’s because I’d expect you to learn your lesson as town too

 

[Comrade Khan]

Mitch should be null, he has one fucking post. the fuck yall going on about

 

[Smart Marx]

Barry made me town in one of his games for once, one of the good guys

 

[Smart Marx]

Mitch should be null, he has one fucking post. the fuck yall going on about

He should be. That's the problem with Poyser's vote and why I'm still not super happy with Tweet's vote hopping.

I do like Tweet's response, though. As far as his reasoning on Poyser goes, but we'll see where it goes.

 

[Poyser]

I am not taking advice on how to play mafia from lesser players at this time.

 

[Tweet]

Nah Mitch id probably expect him to try and keep out of it a bit tbh. I’ve never seen him play as mafia so ? Can’t have been scum much and first instinct is to not really want to be on a mislynch wagon. It’s a trap that OMB regularly falls into

You've never seen him play scum and yet you feel like you can make accurate assumptions about what he would do as scum?

 

[Tweet]

Barry made me town in one of his games for once, one of the good guys